Find the limit of xsin(pi*x) at infinity

  • Thread starter Thread starter allergic
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Infinity Limit
AI Thread Summary
The limit of the function f(x) = xsin(πx) as x approaches infinity does not exist due to its oscillatory nature. While some argue it approaches positive infinity, the oscillation means the limit fails to settle at a specific value. The discussion highlights that the inclusion of π in the function's argument is irrelevant to the limit's behavior. If x is considered an integer, a limit may exist, but this is not the general case. Overall, the consensus is that the limit does not exist for real numbers.
allergic
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Since the function f(x)=xsin[(pi)x] oscillates, shouldn't the limit as x -> infinity not exist? i was told that it is positive infinity.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If your function really is f(x)=x\sin(\pi{x}) , then you're right.
(That is, a limit doesn't exist)
 
Last edited:
Note,that "pi" in the argument is totally unimportant.A certain rescaling would eliminate it...:wink:

Daniel.
 
Unless, of course, x is supposed to be an integer variable; in which case a limit does exist..:wink:
 
Of course,Arildno,mathematicians thought of it and decided to use the "n" (middle Latin alphabet letters,in general) for the INTEGER/natural numbers.Just the same way as "x" stands for reals and "z" for complex...:wink:


Daniel.
 
I'll just post for a face change..:smile:
 
No face change needed...I can handle "winks"...:wink:

Daniel.
 
Back
Top