Find the volume of the solid of revolution.

s3a
Messages
814
Reaction score
8

Homework Statement


Problem:
Find the volume of the solid of revolution obtained by rotating the area bounded by the curves y = x^2 – 2 and y = 0 about the line y = -1. Consider only that part above y = -1.

Solution:
The solution is attached as TheSolution.jpeg.

Homework Equations


Integration.

The Attempt at a Solution


I get everything the solution did except for the part with the PQ = 1 - |y| = 1 - (-y) = 1 + y = y + 1.

Could someone please explain that part for me?

Any input would be greatly appreciated!
 

Attachments

  • TheSolution.jpg
    TheSolution.jpg
    42.8 KB · Views: 448
Physics news on Phys.org
It is just the radius of revolution of the dydx element, : ##y_{upper}-y_{lower}=y -(-1)##.
 
Sorry, I double-posted.
 
Y_lower = the line about which we are rotating, right?

As for the upper part of the radius, I don't see why y_upper = y.
 
s3a said:
Y_lower = the line about which we are rotating, right?

As for the upper part of the radius, I don't see why y_upper = y.

You have a little dydx square located at the variable point (x,y) in the interior of your area that you are integrating over the area. It is the distance from that variable (x,y) point to the line y = -1 that is the radius of revolution.
 
Why is ##y_upper## = y (a variable) if the parabola is bounded above by a constant function (y = 0)?

Why isn't it ##y_upper – y_lower## = 0 - (-y) = y (such that the third dimension of the volume is 2π × y instead of 2π × (y + 1))?

Also, why does the solution say 1 - |y| = 1 - (-y) = 1 + y = y + 1 instead of y - (-1) = y + 1? (I know the final answer is the same; I'm asking about the difference in getting to the final answer.)
 
s3a said:
Why is ##y_{upper}## = y (a variable) if the parabola is bounded above by a constant function (y = 0)?

You want the radius of rotation of the little dydx square. You want its distance from ##y=-1##.

Why isn't it ##y_{upper} – y_{lower}## = 0 - (-y) = y (such that the third dimension of the volume is 2π × y instead of 2π × (y + 1))?

We are talking about the upper and lower ends of the radius of rotation. The upper end is at the dydx square and the lower end is ##y=-1##.

Also, why does the solution say 1 - |y| = 1 - (-y) = 1 + y = y + 1 instead of y - (-1) = y + 1? (I know the final answer is the same; I'm asking about the difference in getting to the final answer.)

I have no idea why he wrote it that way.
 
s3a said:
Also, why does the solution say 1 - |y| = 1 - (-y) = 1 + y = y + 1 instead of y - (-1) = y + 1? (I know the final answer is the same; I'm asking about the difference in getting to the final answer.)
I'd guess that the way the person who wrote the solution was thinking about it is that the distance from the line y=-1 to the point (x,y) is 1, the distance between the x-axis and the line y=-1, minus |y|, the distance from (x,y) to the x-axis.
 
Thanks guys, I get it now! :)
 
Back
Top