The discussion focuses on finding three-digit numbers \( x \) such that \( y = x^2 \) and the last three digits of \( y \) equal \( x \). The solutions identified are \( x = 376 \) and \( x = 625 \), leading to \( y = 141376 \) and \( y = 390625 \) respectively. The mathematical approach involves modular arithmetic, specifically \( x^2 \equiv x \pmod{1000} \), and utilizes a Python 3 script to efficiently enumerate potential solutions through recursion.
PREREQUISITES
Understanding of modular arithmetic, specifically \( x^2 \equiv x \pmod{m} \)
Familiarity with Python 3 programming, particularly recursion
Knowledge of number theory concepts such as coprimality and prime factorization
Basic understanding of algorithm efficiency and complexity analysis
NEXT STEPS
Study modular arithmetic applications in number theory
Learn about Python recursion techniques for problem-solving
Explore efficient algorithms for finding modular solutions
Investigate the implications of coprimality in number theory
USEFUL FOR
Mathematicians, computer scientists, and programmers interested in number theory, algorithm optimization, and modular arithmetic applications.
Clearly for $x$ coprime to $1000$, the only solutions are the trivial $x = 0$ and $x = 1$, so all nontrivial solutions for $x$ must be divisible by either $2$ or $5$, or both. This leaves us with about $600$ possible candidates. Now it should be clear that if a solution works for $1000$, it will also work for $100$, and for $10$. Let's try and find the solutions for $10$:
$$x^2 \equiv x \pmod{10} \tag{2}$$
We have $5$ potential solutions here, namely $2, 4, 5, 6, 8$ (modulo $10$). Let's check each of them manually, some calculations show that only $5$ and $6$ work. So the solutions must have either $5$ or $6$ as a last digit. Let's now extend our search to $100$, armed with this information (which reduces the set of possible solutions considerably):
$$x^2 \equiv x \pmod{100} \tag{3}$$
We know from the previous step that the potential solutions are $5, 6, 15, 16, \cdots$. A short exhaustive search tells us that only $25$ and $76$ work. Finally, we have narrowed down the search enough to look for the real solutions:
$$x^2 \equiv x \pmod{1000} \tag{4}$$
The only possible solutions are $25, 76, 125, 176, \cdots$. Again, trying those 20 potential solutions shows that only $376$ and $625$ work. Therefore, the solutions are $x \in \{ 0, \, 1, \, 376, \, 625 \}$. QED.
This might look like a non-answer given the amount of trial and error involved, but consider that we've only had to try $45$ potential candidates instead of the original $600$, and the cost of this algorithm is asymptotically logarithmic, for instance, finding the solutions with $m = 100000$ would only take $85$ trials, quite efficient.
Here's an Python 3 script implementing the algorithm outlined above, using recursion, for powers of $10$:
Code:
# Work count
work = 0
def Verify(x, m):
global work
work += 1
return pow(x, 2, 10**m) == x
def Solve(m):
# Solutions
found = []
if m == 1:
for x in [2, 4, 5, 6, 8]: # Precomputed
if Verify(x, m):
found.append(x)
return found
possible = Solve(m - 1)
for p in possible:
for x in range(p, 10**m, 10**(m - 1)):
if Verify(x, m):
found.append(x)
return found
def Enumerate(m):
global work
work = 0
found = Solve(m)
# Add trivial solutions
found.append(0)
found.append(1)
found.sort()
print("Solutions are {" + ', '.join(str(x) for x in found) + "}.")
print("Checked " + str(work) + " candidates.")
Which gives us (spaces added for readability):
Code:
>>> Enumerate(1) # For 10
Solutions are {0, 1, 5, 6}.
Checked 5 candidates.
>>> Enumerate(2) # For 100
Solutions are {0, 1, 25, 76}.
Checked 25 candidates.
>>> Enumerate(3) # For 1000
Solutions are {0, 1, 376, 625}.
Checked 45 candidates.
>>> Enumerate(5) # For 100000
Solutions are {0, 1, 9376, 90625}.
Checked 85 candidates.
>>> Enumerate(8) # For 100000000
Solutions are {0, 1, 12890625, 87109376}.
Checked 145 candidates.
Interestingly, there are only two nontrivial solutions for any power of $10$, and these two solutions add up to $-1$ modulo said power, suggesting that there might exist an analytic solution to this problem, though the prime factorisations of the solutions display no obvious pattern apart from a large number of powers of $2$ and $5$.
So if a better way to do this exists, I'd be interested to see it. It is worth noting that the condition $x^2 \equiv x \pmod{m}$ implies $x^n \equiv x \pmod{m}$ for all $n > 0$, but I could not find how to use this property, sadly.
#3
Albert1
1,221
0
Re: find the value of x and y
Albert said:
x=abc is a three digits number
y=$x^2$
the last 3 digits of y is also equal to abc
that is y=?abc
please find x and y
y-x =$x^2-x =x(x-1)$ must be a multiple of 1000
for 1000=$2^3 \times 5^3 =8\times 125$
further more x and (x-1) are coprime
if x is a multiple of 125 then x-1 must be a multiple of 8---------(1)
if x is a multiple of 8 then x-1 must be a multiple of 125---------(2)
so the possible solutions meet restriction of (1) and (2) will be x=376 , and x=625