Finding electric flux through a surface, simple problem, whats wrong?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the electric flux through a cube with specified electric field values on its top and bottom faces. The calculations initially showed a net flux of -176,000 N·m²/C, but confusion arose regarding the signs of the flux contributions from each face. After further attempts, the participant calculated the total flux as -1.104E-6 N·m²/C, leading to a total charge of -9.7704E-6 C using the equation Flux = Qtotal/Eo. Despite following the correct methodology, the participant faced issues with an online submission system, prompting concerns about potential errors in units or significant figures. The participant plans to consult their professor for clarification on the discrepancies.
mr_coffee
Messages
1,613
Reaction score
1
At each point on the surface of the cube shown in Figure 23-27, the electric field is parallel to the z axis. The length of each edge of the cube is 4.0 m. On the top face of the cube E = -40 k N/C, and on the bottom face of the cube E = +29 k N/C. Determine the net charge contained within the cube.
Image: here

Flux = (29E3 N/C)(4.0)^2;
Flux = 464000 k going up
Flux = (-40E3 N/C)(4.0)^2;
Flux = -640000 k going down
Net Flux = -640000 + 464000 = -176000

I submitted it and was inncorrect,
So i tried added them together and i got 1.104E6, that's the flux, now I found an equation that says, Flux = Qtotal/Eo, so I took Flux*Eo = Qtotal and got 9.7704E-6 and it is still wrong!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
When finding the flux through a surface, think in terms of inward (-) and outward (+).
mr_coffee said:
Flux = (29E3 N/C)(4.0)^2;
Flux = 464000 k going up
That should be negative, since it points inward.
Flux = (-40E3 N/C)(4.0)^2;
Flux = -640000 k going down
This is also inward, so negative.
Net Flux = -640000 + 464000 = -176000
Redo this, since both are negative.

I submitted it and was inncorrect,
So i tried added them together and i got 1.104E6, that's the flux, now I found an equation that says, Flux = Qtotal/Eo, so I took Flux*Eo = Qtotal and got 9.7704E-6 and it is still wrong!
Signs matter! The flux is negative.
 
So i got -1.104E-6 for the Flux. So Q = -1.104E-6*8.85E-12 = -9.7704E-6? I have only one more chance so i have to make sure I'm doing this one right, thank you!
 
Well... does that follow from what I said? And do you think what I said is accurate? :wink:
 
ahh it was wrong, what did i mess up?
 
mr_coffee said:
ahh it was wrong, what did i mess up?
Nothing that I can see. But those on-line systems can be picky. (Units, significant figures, etc.)
 
yeah i hate this system, i'll ask the professor tomarrow what's up, thanks!
 
Back
Top