Finding the ratio of the emfs of two cells by a potentiometer

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the ratio of the electromotive forces (emfs) of two primary cells connected in series with different polarities using a potentiometer. The balancing lengths measured are 350 cm for the same polarity and 50 cm for opposite polarities, leading to a calculated ratio of 4:3 for E1 and E2. Participants express confusion about why emfs are added in the same polarity case and subtracted in the opposite case, seeking a clearer understanding of the underlying principles. Circuit diagrams are shared to aid in visualizing the setup, and there is a suggestion to apply Kirchhoff's laws for better comprehension. The conversation emphasizes the need for intuitive explanations alongside mathematical calculations in physics problems.
betaleonis
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
I don't have a clear perception of how the following question is answered:

"Two primary cells of emfs E1 and E2 respectively are joined in series with (i) the same polarity, and (ii) opposite polarities. The combination is connected through a galvanometer and a jockey to a potentiometer. The balancing lengths in the two cases are found to be 350 cm and 50 cm respectively. Find the ratio of E1 and E2."

With a little bit of calculation I get the answer, 4:3. With the knowledge of the basic principle of potentiometer and from what I have learned from my physics textbook, the sum of the two emfs is proportional to the length given in the first case, and when E2 is subtracted from E1, the result is proportional to the length given in the second case. I don't quite understand why the emfs are added when they are joined with the same polarity and subtracted when they are joined the other way round.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF.
Is this a homework problem?
Can you draw the circuit diagram showing how you connect the cells, potentiometer and galvanometer.
 
Thanks for the reply.

Yes, it can be viewed as a homework problem (though answering the question isn't exactly part of my homework).

I have roughly drawn the following circuit diagrams in reference to the question:

https://www.physicsforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=71449&stc=1&d=1405709293
 
To attach a file, while posting by “Quick Reply” or “Edit” a recent post, click “Go Advanced”,
then scroll down to “Additional Options”, “Attach Files”, click “Manage Attachments”.
Click “Browse”, select your file, then click “Upload”. Wait till done, then “Close this window”.
“Preview Post” and you will see your file attached.
 
I did that at first; but ended up opening the file in another tab, copying its URL, inserting it in that post, and deleting the attachment. :redface: My apologies.
 
So, you've worked this out now?
 
I know the answer to the question and how to answer it, but I don't have an intuitive explanation as to why I answered it like the way I did. I still don't know why E2 is added to and subtracted from E1 in the first case and second case respectively. Also, is there any other way to come up with a solution?
 

Attachments

  • PF.jpg
    PF.jpg
    17.5 KB · Views: 640
Does the attached file help?
Think of the V axis as the potentiometer wire.
 

Attachments

  • Sum&Diff.jpg
    Sum&Diff.jpg
    22.3 KB · Views: 621
Thank you. :approve:
 
  • #10
It may help to think in terms of Kirchoff 2 in problems like this one.
 
Back
Top