How to Derive the Wave Equations for Photons?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jb646
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Photons Wave
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on deriving wave equations for photons using the relativistic energy expression E^2=p^2c^2+(m_0)^2(c)^4. Participants express confusion about the problem, noting that photons are massless and suggesting that the approach may not align with how quantum fields operate. They emphasize that photons are quanta of fields and that the appropriate equations stem from classical electrodynamics, specifically Maxwell's equations. The conversation highlights the complexity of applying canonical quantization to derive the necessary differential equations. Ultimately, the consensus is that the problem's premise may be flawed, as photons do not have a traditional wave equation.
jb646
Messages
10
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Use the relativistic expression for energy E^2=p^2c^2+(m_0)^2(c)^4 to find a wave equations for photons. Find a solution for ψ and compare to the electric field (hint: photons are massless, E_op=ih(d/dt) and p_op=h/i(d/dx)


Homework Equations


the only equations i know are the ones given in the problem


The Attempt at a Solution


if somebody could please point me in the right direction, i do not have the mental power to understand what i should even try to do first. Thanks for any help you can provide.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Photons are quanta of fields, it doesn't really work the way your problem suggests.

The differential equation for the quantized electromagnetic field is obtained by applying a canonical quantization* to the classical electrodynamic equation for the one-forms describing the field at a classical level.

* very tricky issue.
 
jb646 said:

Homework Statement


Use the relativistic expression for energy E^2=p^2c^2+(m_0)^2(c)^4 to find a wave equations for photons. Find a solution for ψ and compare to the electric field (hint: photons are massless, E_op=ih(d/dt) and p_op=h/i(d/dx)


Homework Equations


the only equations i know are the ones given in the problem


The Attempt at a Solution


if somebody could please point me in the right direction, i do not have the mental power to understand what i should even try to do first. Thanks for any help you can provide.
Okay, if E_op=ih(d/dt), then what would E_op2 be?

bigubau said:
Photons are quanta of fields, it doesn't really work the way your problem suggests.

The differential equation for the quantized electromagnetic field is obtained by applying a canonical quantization* to the classical electrodynamic equation for the one-forms describing the field at a classical level.

* very tricky issue.
I fail to see how that is helpful.
 
Redbelly98 said:
I fail to see how that is helpful.

The problem is wrong. The photon has no wave equation. The electric field has a field equation, but in the classical sense, as it can be deduced from Maxwell's equations (for simplicity, in vacuum).
 
Thread 'Help with Time-Independent Perturbation Theory "Good" States Proof'
(Disclaimer: this is not a HW question. I am self-studying, and this felt like the type of question I've seen in this forum. If there is somewhere better for me to share this doubt, please let me know and I'll transfer it right away.) I am currently reviewing Chapter 7 of Introduction to QM by Griffiths. I have been stuck for an hour or so trying to understand the last paragraph of this proof (pls check the attached file). It claims that we can express Ψ_{γ}(0) as a linear combination of...
Back
Top