MATLAB Fit data with a curve in MATLAB

AI Thread Summary
To achieve an accurate fit for the provided x and y data, the discussion emphasizes the necessity of constraining the model due to the infinite number of functions that can fit the data exactly. A polynomial of degree N-1 can fit N data points, but for meaningful predictions and interpolations, a mathematical model grounded in a priori principles is recommended. Non-linear least-squares regression, particularly using the Simplex method, is suggested for robust fitting. The importance of specifying constraints, such as the polynomial order, is highlighted to avoid ill-posed problems. Additionally, plotting the data on logarithmic coordinates is advised as a potential method to identify the underlying function shape. Extrapolations from the fitted model should be approached with caution, as they may not reliably represent the data's behavior beyond the observed range.
quin
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
Hi friends.
I want to fit my x datas and y datas with a function in the most exact way.my data is:

Code:
x=[0.3 0.5 0.7 0.9 1 1.3 1.4 1.5 2  3 5 7 9 10 30 50 70 90 100];
y=[13.4347 8.3372 6.3107 5.27 4.93 4.28 4.14 4.0199 3.6349 3.3178 3.1282 3.0691 3.0432 3.0354 3.0043 3.0016 3.0008 3.0005 3.0004];
and I ploted y vs x

can you give me the most suitable formula for the curve of these data?

thank you so much
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It is possible to EXACTLY fit any finite number of [x,y] data pairs using the method of divided differences. N data points can be fitted exactly by a polynomial of degree N-1.
If you want something else out of the data, such as the ability to interpolate or parameters that have an actual meaning according to some model, then you will have to construct a mathematical model from a priori principles.
Your best bet then would be to use a non-linear least-square regression (weighted, if you can weigh the data) that will find the best fit of the data to the mathematical model. I recommend the Simplex method as being very robust and not too dependent on the initial estimates of the parameters (coefficients, constants, etc) in the model.
In the long run, the method you choose should be driven by what you already know about the source of the data, and by what you expect to get out of the data.
One caveat I feel must be made: don't expect extrapolations to mean much. Extrapolations are toys by which engineers, economists, and other non-scientists delude themselves.
 
you are right but I just want to predict a few next points for taking them as my initial numbers for my program

so is there anybody who knows a way in MATLAB for finding the formula of plot of my points?
 
The problem is you haven't given any constraints for your function. There are an infinite number of functions which fit your data exactly. You need to constrain the model by saying, for example, it should be a polynomial of order 18 (as tadchem suggested). This continuous model would at least make any extrapolation attempt somewhat dependant on the data.

MATLAB can solve the problem (in many different ways) once you do this. Until you do this, the problem is hugely ill-posed.
 
MikeyW said:
The problem is you haven't given any constraints for your function. There are an infinite number of functions which fit your data exactly. You need to constrain the model by saying, for example, it should be a polynomial of order 18 (as tadchem suggested). This continuous model would at least make any extrapolation attempt somewhat dependant on the data.

MATLAB can solve the problem (in many different ways) once you do this. Until you do this, the problem is hugely ill-posed.

you are right but I tested a polynomial of order -6 to 6 . But it won't predict the continuation of my real function in a good way!
So what formula do you suggest for fitthing these datas?

thank you so much
 
Just for starters, try plotting your [x,y] pairs on logarithmic coordinates. That may at least give you a hint of what the function may look like.
 

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
5K
Replies
12
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
8K
Replies
5
Views
44K
Replies
1
Views
9K
Back
Top