Flyback Voltage Spikes Emitted From an Unprotected Relay

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
CAMTWO
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
Had an issue with electrical gremlins and blown sensors also 3 ECU's after buying a wiring harness from a Veteran in the industry. Back when this guy started Flyback wasnt even considered and besides the harnesses are installed in kitcars and hotrods built all around the world.All these wiring kits are plagued by flyback emitted from the huge amounts of cheap unprotected diodes they utilize. My ECU expert said I was spiking the heck out of my ECU with flyback due to lack of circuit protection
I research the phenomenon and came up with the fact they weren't using protected diodes in their relays they utilize in a multitude of wiring harnesses for cars and also go into factory built kitcars in massachusettes..

I was having huge issues and have accrued over $1000 in blown sensors and ignition modules and ECU's..wiring harness guy said it was my install skills ... Its his electrical engineering skills that come into question here.

I bought the protected relays and the problems instantly went away as fuelpump relay,horn relay,power doorlocks and power windows also door poppers and trubk popper ,ecu relay,starter solenoid and fuel injectors were the issue causing the flyback through a relay block with cheap chinese relays that are unprotected by a schottky diode.

Now I am trying to save people from headaches as well as lives from being lost and I am being banned from forums like some crackpot spreading false news but its the wiring guys that sell these kits getting me banned.This is a fact and my 1st Amendment rights are being violated too. I need a Good civil rights attorney too if anyone knows one..
 
Attachments
  • Two automotive relays side by side on a brown textured cloth: a black Rhapsody 40/30A 12VDC relay with pin labels 85, 87a, 87, 86 and 30, and a white SH049G relay with a similar pin diagram.
    IMG_20211216_232425.jpg
    57 KB · Views: 199
  • Screenshot of a forum email reply with a product photo of a black automotive power relay and a TE Connectivity part listing showing a 5-pin relay with price tiers, specifications and a Download Datasheet link.
    Screenshot 2021-12-16 180128.jpg
    27.5 KB · Views: 170
  • Two eBay order history entries dated May 13, 2021, sold by bmwsalepro, each for an Ford Mustang 5.0 engine computer repair and return service priced at US $102.99.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 040835.jpg
    36.7 KB · Views: 185
  • Screenshot of an eBay order history listing three automotive ECU and switch purchases from May 2021, with order numbers, sellers and item prices.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 040953.jpg
    42.8 KB · Views: 193
  • Text-only excerpt on flyback voltage; the small inline diagram shows a relay coil with a diode connected across it in reverse polarity, labelled as a diode snubber.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 200034.jpg
    77.5 KB · Views: 221
  • Screenshot of a Hot Rodders forum error page reading 'Oops! We ran into some problems' and 'You have been banned for the following reason: Spam.' Header shows classic and muscle cars.
    Screenshot 2021-12-18 135941.jpg
    33.7 KB · Views: 221
  • Screenshot of a Wikipedia knowledge panel for Flyback diode, with a small oscilloscope photo showing a sharp voltage spike on a grid.
    Screenshot 2021-12-18 131743.jpg
    34.7 KB · Views: 183
Heres the schematic for the relay..They double up on soma and triple up on another circuit and feed 3 with 1 relay and with a subpar 15 amp fuse too.

They say I am the guy whos creating the issues...

What does the experts say about this?
 
Attachments
  • Table titled Fuse and Relay Key listing four fuse and relay designations with fuse sizes: O2 and Mass Air Flow Sensor (Relay A) 15 AMP; Fuel Pump (Relay B) 20 AMP; Coil and TFI Module (Relay C) 15 AMP; ECM, Injectors, IAC (Relay D) 20 AMP.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 225949.jpg
    33.7 KB · Views: 198
  • Photo of a black automotive wiring harness with bundled looms, multi-pin connectors, red and black wires, a red-and-black fused lead, and a bank of relay sockets at lower right.
    s-l500.jpg
    17.5 KB · Views: 171
  • Photo of a Ron Francis Wiring Ford 5.0 EFI harness installation manual cover, showing a black wiring harness with connectors, a red wire loop and a relay block on a white background.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 225524.jpg
    38.8 KB · Views: 181
  • Numbered installation instructions 24 to 27 for a wiring harness, with step 25b highlighted in yellow: an 18 gauge purple TFI START wire should only be hot while cranking, otherwise an undesirable rev limiter at 2000-3000 RPM results.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 225854.jpg
    70.3 KB · Views: 192
  • Table titled Fuse and Relay Key listing four designations with fuse sizes: O2 & Mass Air Flow Sensor (Relay A) 15 AMP; Fuel Pump (Relay B) 20 AMP; Coil & TFI Module (Relay C) 15 AMP; ECM, Injectors, IAC (Relay D) 20 AMP.
    Screenshot 2021-12-17 225949.jpg
    33.7 KB · Views: 199
  • Photo of an oscilloscope screen showing a sharp negative voltage spike that decays back to a flat baseline, with a Wikipedia knowledge panel for flyback diode beside it.
    Screenshot 2021-12-18 131743.jpg
    34.7 KB · Views: 191
What do you expect PF to do about it?

When the relay coil is close to the driver on a PCB, it is easy to place a flyback diode. But when they are far apart, the diode needs to be with the driver where the polarity is known, with a twisted pair to power the remote relay coil.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Averagesupernova and nsaspook
I find this rant a bit on the silly side. If someone in some industry has 'issues' that are causing so many problems in said industry, then come up with a better product. I'm not tell you to go pound sand, just realize that many times problems like these go on for years since not everyone involved is smart enough to realize why the failures are occurring. I have to assume that you are a builder of custom cars/street rods. Since you now realize what is happening, the ball is in your court. Make builds with equipment that doesn't cause the issue. Your reputation as a builder of a quality product will rise.
-
Also realize that many many automotive relays have no flyback protection. The circuit that drives them is taking the task of suppressing the spike generated by the falling field in the relay coil. A flyback diode built into a relay can be a risky thing for the amateur to be messing with since a reversal of polarity will fry the diode and may blow the output device that is driving it. Coming on here explaining about flyback as if it is a new thing is like me coming out with big news about how people get wet if they don't come in out of the rain. If you couldn't tell, I used to work in the automotive electronics industry.
 
Baluncore said:
What do you expect PF to do about it?
Exactly. This jerk newbie already had his first attempt at this thread start deleted with a similar message, and this repost of a deleted thread earns this newbie a permanent ban from PF. Thread is locked.