Force Exerted by Roads of Length x & Separation x - Physics Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter jingu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the gravitational force exerted between two parallel roads of equal length and separation, each having different masses. Participants suggest using the gravitational force equation F=G(m1*m2)/r^2, but the complexity arises from integrating over continuous mass elements. Confusion is noted regarding the integration process and the variables used, with suggestions to differentiate between mass elements to simplify calculations. Ultimately, the conversation leads to a verification of the final force calculation, with participants confirming the derived formula. The problem highlights the challenges of applying calculus concepts in physics, especially for those with limited experience.
jingu
Messages
26
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



There are two roads of length x.There separation is also x.They have mass k and p.Than what is the force exerted by one on the other.

Homework Equations



I think f=gmM/R^2 IS THE EQUATION TO BE USED.

The Attempt at a Solution


When I solved (dx)^2 was coming during integration which is not solvable for me.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
You have not shown us how you end up with your problem, so we cannot help.
 
Please show exactly what you did so we can see where you went wrong. :)
 
all i did is this...

Let a small element of road 1 be dy.Then dm1= (m1/x)dy.Similarly dm2=(m2/x)dy.
dF=(G(dm1)(dm2))/y^2
dF=(Gm1*m2*(dy)^2)/y^2
∫dF=∫(Gm1*m2*(dy)^2)/y^2
here the problem begins we have to integrate from x to 2x.WRT to (dy)^2...now can we integrate this... how to solve with (dy)^2?...I think I am going in a wrong path.guide me.
 
Do not use 'y' for both dm1 and dm2. Use different symbols, say 'u' and 'v'.
 
voko said:
Do not use 'y' for both dm1 and dm2. Use different symbols, say 'u' and 'v'.

I am getting confused there are so many variables... Please give me the description of how to approach the problem.Everything else will be my work.I have to submit it tommorow.
 
Last edited:
$$

dm_1 = \frac {m_1} {x} du

\\

dm_2 = \frac {m_2} {x} dv

$$
 
You are considering the force ##dF## by the infintesimal mass element ##dm_1## on one rod (road?) on another infintesimal element ##dm_2## on the other. Then summing up all the contributions. Consider some mass element (with fractional length ##du/x##) on one and another mass element (of fractional length ##dv/x##) on the other.
 
voko said:
$$

dm_1 = \frac {m_1} {x} du

\\

dm_2 = \frac {m_2} {x} dv

$$

dF=(Gm1m2dvdu)/x^2*r^2 here r is the distance between them ,then r equals what...?This question would be easy if there is a point mass and a continuous body...but here both are continuous...?
Then this need to integrated but with respect to what...?
Please show me the calculations ...I am studying this topic for first time...help...I am trying this question since 2 days...
 
  • #10
If you have an integrand involving "du" and "dv", what do you think it should be integrated with respect to?
 
  • #11
The integration variables are u and v, which should be obvious from 'du' and 'dv'.

What is the topic you are studying?
 
  • #12
voko said:
The integration variables are u and v, which should be obvious from 'du' and 'dv'.

What is the topic you are studying?

Various types of forces...
 
  • #13
jingu said:
Various types of forces...

But your difficulty has nothing to do with the topic. You are having problems with integration, which is basic calculus.
 
  • #14
I am not able to understand what u all are telling...?explain in detail...I am in 10 grade so Iam not familiar with calculus...Only very basic I know...
 
  • #15
jingu said:
I am not able to understand what u all are telling...?explain in detail...I am in 10 grade so Iam not familiar with calculus...Only very basic I know...

Grade 10? Hmm. I do not think you have studied double integrals then.

Do you know what a potential of force is?
 
  • #16
voko said:
Grade 10? Hmm. I do not think you have studied double integrals then.

Do you know what a potential of force is?

NO.That's why I posted it here, i hoped a solution to this problem...but u r not helping me...Give me a full solution so that i can understand it thoroughly... ...
 
  • #17
Can you not consider the road a point mass of k and p separated by x?
 
  • #18
I don't think so...I am expecting a solution but no one is ready to give...
 
  • #19
You will not get a solution in this forum, it is against the rules.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #20
Look again at the suggestion given by barryj in post 17. I suspect that this is the approach expected for someone in tenth grade.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #21
Agreed - considering them as point particles is the easiest and most reasonable approach to the problem.

However, would the distance between the two depend on the set up?

Case 1: Suppose the rods are oriented vertically and are parallel (ie. similar to considering two lines x=0 and x=10). Then the two point particles are separated by a distance d=10.

Case 2: Suppose the rods lay along a line and that their ends are separated by a distance d=10; that is imagine two pencils on a desk laying one in front of the other - then the value of r in the equation for force is not simply d.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #22
thank u everyone ! I think the answer is (Gm1m2)\4x^2...please verify and sorry to everyone.I was not familiar with these rules...
 
  • #23
(Gm1m2)\4x^2 Why 4x^2?
 
  • #24
We will treat both of the point masses at the centre of the rod.?So distance between them is x+x/2 +x/2 = 2x...Am I wrong...Or the answer would be only Gm1m2/x^2
 
  • #25
How are the rods situated? Like this: | | or like this: _ _?
 
  • #26
they are like this _ _. My answer is correct or not...?
 
Last edited:
  • #27
Approximately correct. An exact answer requires some calculus. But it is not as difficult as I originally thought, _ _ makes things much simpler.
 
  • #28
then how we will do using calculus..?
 
  • #29
Solve a simpler problem first. You have a rod of mass M, lying on the x-axis. Its ends are at x = 0 and x = d. Find the force from the rod on a point of mass m, also lying on the x-axis, at x = u.
 
  • #30
F= (GMm)/(u^2-du) here du is the product of coordinates not differentiation.
Answer is this...
 
  • #31
Good. Now that you know F(u) acting on a material point at x = u of mass m, let there be another rod between x = 2d and x = 3d, of mass m2. What is the net force?
 
  • #32
Net force on point mass m? It will depend on the positions of m2 and m bcoz gravitational force is always attractive so there will be two cases ...please tell whether u > 3d...or d<u<2d
 
  • #33
Net force on the second rod from the first rod.

You know the location of the first rod: 0 ≤ x ≤ d. You know the location of the second rod: 2d ≤ x ≤ 3d.

You know the force from the first rod on a point at x = u.
 
  • #34
I solved it I came up with this answer F= (GMm ln(4/3))/d^2...please verify...
 
  • #35
I get the same answer. Very good!
 
  • #36
thank you very much...Are u sure that the answer is the same...?
 
Back
Top