Great Explanations: Feynman & Sagan

  • Thread starter Thread starter stabu
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on gathering recommendations for exceptional explainers and explanations across various fields, not limited to physics or science. Participants reference notable figures and their works, including William Feller on probability, Roger Penrose's "Road to Reality," and Jakob Bronowski's "Ascent of Man," which discusses Pythagoras' theorem. Richard Dawkins' "Modern Scientific Writing" is highlighted as a key resource, though it raises concerns about the balance between popularization and depth, often catering to a lay audience. Lisa Randall's "Warped Passages" is noted for its effective explanation of extra dimensions. Additionally, Steven Strogatz's New York Times columns on mathematics are praised for their clarity, particularly his piece on probability. The conversation also includes a philosophical analogy attributed to Buddha about existence, emphasizing the improbability of life. Leon Lederman's analogy comparing physics to an invisible soccer ball is mentioned as another effective explanation.
stabu
Messages
26
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I wanted to collate a list of either great explainers or great explanations. Would you like to suggest one or two? Style:

Feynman - we on Earth as a tiny insect in corner of swimming pool.
Sagan - cube as shadow of a tesseract

I'm sure these are familiar to people here. However, it need not be Physics or even just science.

I'm also reading Modern Scientific Writing by Dawkins and trying to pull some out of there too.

Thanks in advance!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
William Feller on probability
Roger Penrose, somewhere in his Road to Reality book
Jakob Bronowski in his Ascent of Man, especially explaining how Pythagoras' theorem may have come about.
 
Sir Ray Lankester "Diversion of a Naturalist"
D'Arcy Thompson "Growth and Form"
 
Of course, Richard Dawkin's "Book of scientific writing" would appear to be the first port of call for somebody interested in quality scientific explanations, but here we encounter a problem: popularization tends to become the main priority. No bad thing in and of itself. However, the target audience is then different. Many of these explanations turn out to be for the layman, so the the reader interested in learnng in depth is left unsatisfied.
 
Lisa Randall does a good job of explaining extra dimensions in her book Warped Passages.
 
Buddha said something along these lines, concerning the fact YOU exist.
' Think of the World covered in water. Toss in one life preserver that gets blown from all 4 directions. Think of a turtle that surfaces every hundred years, [what the hey a thou], for a breath. The odds and/or circumstances of when the turtle's head will come up in the life preserver explains how YOU are here. '
 
Leon Lederman with his analogy of physics and an invisible soccer ball.
 
Back
Top