Hard Disk - Motherboard Compatibility

  • Thread starter Thread starter rahulkhajuria
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Disk Hard
AI Thread Summary
Swapping hard disks between two PCs is generally safe, especially since both drives are SATA, with one operating at 1.5 Gb/s and the other at 3 Gb/s. A 1.5 Gb/s SATA cable can be used on a 3 Gb/s drive without issues. However, caution is advised regarding power supply capacity; the 250-watt power supply in PC 1 may be insufficient, and a minimum of 300 watts is recommended for stable operation. It is important to consult the manuals for both hard drives to ensure compatibility and to check for any specific requirements. Overall, hard drive and motherboard incompatibility is rare, but ensuring adequate power supply is crucial when adding or swapping components.
rahulkhajuria
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
I have 2 P.C.s as follows

P.C.1 : 865G/GVM3-V (MS -7101 V2.0) M-ATX MicroStar Motherboard
Pentium 4 Dual Core Processor
80 GB WD Hard Disk 1.5 Gb/s
512 MB DDR1 RAM
250 Watt Power Supply
Bought in 2006

P.C.2 : M2N68-AM SE2 ASUS Motherboard
ATHALON Processor
250 GB Seagate BARRACUDA 7200.10 Hard Disk 3 Gb/s
2 GB DDR2 RAM
400 Watt Power Supply
Bought in 2009

The Hard Disk on P.C.1 has the following thing written on it - 5v ... .48A
12v ... .50A

The Hard Disk on P.C.2 has the following thing written on it - 5v ... .72A
12v ... .52A

Now , I want to install the Hard Disk on P.C. 1 on P.C. 2 & Vice Versa .
However , I am concerned that when I try this out what if there is some spark or short-circuit due to some sort of power-mismatch because of which I end up killing one of the motherboards or HardDisks . Can I safely just swap the 2 Hard Disks ? Is there any more information I need to give regarding these P.Cs ?

What are the precautions in general that one needs to bear in mind before adding new devices onto a P.C. Or in other words , how does one check whether a certain device will be compatible with a certain system or not ?
 
Last edited:
Computer science news on Phys.org
I have never heard of hard drive, motherboard incompatibility. I wouldn't worry about it, especially since both of those drives are SATA so you don't even need an adapter! Only difference is one is 1.5gb/s sata and one is 3gb/s sata, and I am pretty sure you can just use a 1.5gb/s cord on a 3gb/s, read the manuals for them just in case though.
 
Hard drive swaps should not be an issue. You may have power supply issues with pc 1. 250 watts is marginal. I would be uncomfortable with less than 300 watts with that setup.
 
Well, the date has now passed, and Windows 10 is no longer supported. Hopefully, the readers of this forum have done one of the many ways this issue can be handled. If not, do a YouTube search and a smorgasbord of solutions will be returned. What I want to mention is that I chose to use a debloated Windows from a debloater. There are many available options, e.g., Chris Titus Utilities (I used a product called Velotic, which also features AI to prevent your computer from overheating etc...
I have been idly browsing what Apple have to offer with their new iPhone17. There is mention of 'Vapour cooling' to deal with the heat generated. Would that be the same sort of idea that was used in 'Heat Pipes' where water evaporated at the processor end and liquid water was returned from the cool end and back along a wick. At the extreme high power end, Vapour Phase Cooling has been used in multi-kW RF transmitters where (pure) water was pumped to the Anode / or alternative Collector and...

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
12
Views
7K
Replies
62
Views
8K
Replies
23
Views
5K
Back
Top