Has technology ruined the modern newspaper?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BobG
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Technology
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights how modern software for newspaper layout has diminished the unique character of print journalism, particularly in the context of sensational stories like "bus plunges." Such stories, once common, are now rare, despite ongoing incidents worldwide. The traditional typesetting process allowed for creative editing that engaged readers' imaginations, fostering a deeper connection to the narrative. In contrast, the digital age provides immediate access to information but often lacks the strategic editing that made these stories compelling. Readers now receive complete details without the need for contemplation, leading to a less satisfying experience. Additionally, the rise of digital news platforms has shifted consumer preferences, with many opting for online news over print, resulting in reduced demand for traditional newspapers. This shift reflects broader changes in how audiences consume news, favoring convenience and immediacy over the tactile and curated experience of print media.
BobG
Science Advisor
Messages
352
Reaction score
88
Software allowing editors to completely lay out their newspapers have stripped newspapers of all of their character.

Case in point - when's the last time you read a 'bus plunge' story in the newspaper. Years ago, it seemed like you could count on reading a story of a bus load of people plunging into a ravine almost every week. Buses haven't gotten any safer in most of the world - in fact, a more open society in China means we should be able to read even more bus plunge stories - but you almost never see 'bus plunge' stories anymore.

We no longer get to read stories, such as:
Twelve persons were killed and ten were injured when a bus went off the highway and plunged into a 1,000 foot abyss about six miles from Anserma, Central Colombia today. The bus caught fire after landing in the abyss.

In the old days, when newspapers used the old mechanical type sets, they never knew exactly how the newspaper would look until the typesetters were finished laying out the newspapers. The bus plunge stories were great for filling awkward spaces in the newspaper since you could edit out as many extraneous details as necessary to make the story the right length. For example: the last sentence in the above story could easily be deleted without detracting from the story (although including it certainly adds to the aesthetic quality of the story).

Readers' fascination with these stories were a key reason for Hollywood's obsession with having all sorts of vehicles plunging off of mountain roads and bursting into flames in mid-air.

Readers here in Colorado Springs are certainly fascinated by the story when another tourist manages to circumvent the brake temperature check at Glen Cove on the road down Pikes Peak and is rewarded for his cleverness by having his brake fluid boil away. Pikes Peak is a big enough tourist attraction that there's always drivers coming up the mountain to provide an eye witness account of the reactions of the hapless driver trying to navigate the hairpin turns on the road down Pikes Peak before their car ultimately plunges off the side of the mountain, usually killing everyone inside (in one of the more fascinating incidents, the driver turned tried turning off the ignition, upping the challenge to navigating the hairpins with no brakes and and no power steering).

Now we have to be satisfied with perusing bus plunge stories on the web (Bus Plunge!) This is much less satisfying since, once again, the digital age eliminates the need for strategic editing. No more does the reader spend 10 minutes pondering why the bus plunged off the road, how the bus was spotted at the bottom of the ravine, how some of the passengers could have possibly survived a plunge into a 1,000 foot ravine, or what emotions were running through the passengers' eyes as they peered desperately out the windows of the plunging bus. All the details are provided with little need for thought or imagination by the reader. It's just not the same.:frown:
 
Last edited:
Computer science news on Phys.org
That's sad, I was wondering why I hadn't read about any good bus crashes lately. :wink:
 
Good news, BobG!

Bus Plunges, Killing 3 Alabama Students

ATLANTA, Ga., Nov. 20 — A school bus plunged nearly 40 feet off a highway overpass in Huntsville, Ala., on Monday and crashed nose-first into the ground, killing three students and sending 11 others to the intensive care unit, officials said.
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/21/us/21bus.html?_r=1&oref=slogin

There's a photo of police officers yelling at the cameraperson taking the photo. It was actually the front-page image of the NYT for a while (online version), so technology is hardly sidelining the traditional 'bus plunge' story. :biggrin: (This thread is too morbid for me, I'm out of here. :rolleyes:)
 
I don't think technology has hurt the newspapers, directly that is.

Indirectly, people seem less likely to read newspapers, to choices given to readers have perhaps reduced the demand for newspapers.

I used to get the NY Times delievered, but when it became available on-line, I stopped getting the paper. I prefer receiving the news electronically - it saves collecting piles of newspaper - and most of the time I was throwing away about 1/3 - 1/2 of the paper, e.g. the Sports section got tossed - I never cared for it. Most of the society and arts pages got tossed. I preferred substantive news about national and international affairs and events, business and science & technology.

On Sunday, I probably threw out 2/3's of the paper without reading.

Then there is NPR and many other news sources on-line, in addition to the Times website. So technology has given us alternatives to the newspaper.
 
Why read a newspaper when I can get the same information on the TV and radio? (while driving to school or eating dinner)
 
In my discussions elsewhere, I've noticed a lot of disagreement regarding AI. A question that comes up is, "Is AI hype?" Unfortunately, when this question is asked, the one asking, as far as I can tell, may mean one of three things which can lead to lots of confusion. I'll list them out now for clarity. 1. Can AI do everything a human can do and how close are we to that? 2. Are corporations and governments using the promise of AI to gain more power for themselves? 3. Are AI and transhumans...
Sorry if 'Profile Badge' is not the correct term. I have an MS 365 subscription and I've noticed on my Word documents the small circle with my initials in it is sometimes different in colour document to document (it's the circle at the top right of the doc, that, when you hover over it it tells you you're signed in; if you click on it you get a bit more info). Last night I had four docs with a red circle, one with blue. When I closed the blue and opened it again it was red. Today I have 3...

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
10K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
8K
Replies
9
Views
3K
Back
Top