Schools High School Student Unable to Decide Between Math or Physics

AI Thread Summary
A high school junior is struggling to choose between pursuing physics or mathematics, expressing a deep appreciation for both subjects. Despite having a foundational knowledge of notable figures and concepts in each field, the student is advised to delay making a decision. Participants in the discussion suggest continuing to take courses in both subjects during college, emphasizing that it’s common for students to wait until their sophomore year to declare a major. They recommend enrolling in one physics and one math course in college to explore interests further. The conversation also touches on the importance of foundational classes and the timing of career considerations, particularly in relation to graduate school aspirations. Additionally, there is a note that the educational context may vary significantly if the student is outside the U.S. or Canada.
jorgerocha
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Hello,

I am a junior in high school and I can't seem to decide between physics or mathematics. I have always had an affinity for the two subjects since preschool. This is a very difficult decision for me because I enjoy both subjects very much.

My knowledge for both subjects are at a layman's level, but I am aware of some of the subjects of today. For math I know the greats (Euclid, Archimedes, Fermat, Galois, Cantor, Gauss, Euler, Poincare, Bourbaki, Godel, etc.), the current players (Tao, Wiles, Grothenidieck, Conway), and a very basic layman knowledge of the subjects (Topology, Set Theory, Number Theory, Discrete Mathematics, etc.).

The same goes for physics, but I won't list them to not appear pretentious.

Could you please help? I am confused. :frown:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
jorgerocha said:
The same goes for physics, but I won't list them to not appear pretentious.
This literally made me laugh out loud after reading the above part.

Dude, you're in high school, you don't need to decide yet. Just keep taking math and physics and decide later.

Have you taken calculus yet?
 
Most colleges recommend that students not choose a specific major until their sophomore year. It is sufficient that you choose, say, the sciences or the humanities or literature by the time you are choosing a college.
 
Have you taken calculus yet?

At the moment I am taking precalculus, but I am currently taking only college classes at the local university. So, next semester I will take Calculus.
 
jorgerocha said:
At the moment I am taking precalculus, but I am currently taking only college classes at the local university. So, next semester I will take Calculus.
Then you have experienced nearly no math or physics yet. Which is ok! Just don't worry about picking yet.
 
Jorriss said:
Then you have experienced nearly no math or physics yet. Which is ok! Just don't worry about picking yet.

Is there anything you would recommend?
 
jorgerocha said:
Is there anything you would recommend?
In terms of? Course guidance? General university guidance? something else?
 
Jorriss said:
In terms of? Course guidance? General university guidance? something else?
I would say course guidance and career guidance, as in what are the odds of Physics in academia and industry.

ben.richards said:
High School Student Unable to Decide Between Math or Physics

I highly recommend you simplify your desicon-making process by reducing ambiguity, uncertainty and complexity, might I suggest an Integrated appproach.

Could you elaborate?
 
When you're a freshman in college, enroll in one physics course and one math course. Take it from there. Problem solved.
 
  • #10
jorgerocha said:
I would say course guidance and career guidance, as in what are the odds of Physics in academia and industry.

My advice is to listen to this advice exactly.

bcrowell said:
When you're a freshman in college, enroll in one physics course and one math course. Take it from there. Problem solved.
 
  • #11
jorgerocha said:
I would say course guidance and career guidance, as in what are the odds of Physics in academia and industry.

That's a rather complicated question, and there are lots of discussion on this in this forum.

It would probably be best if you wait until junior year to worry about this. The basic classes for math and physics are those that you would need to take for all sorts of things, and you don't have to worry much about career issues until you start thinking about whether you want to go to graduate school.

One thing. I'm assuming that you are in the United States or Canada. If you aren't, then that changes things a lot.
 
Back
Top