Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

How can I explain this?

  1. Nov 5, 2015 #1
    I am tutoring a kid who just started on calculus. Today he asked me if there is a way to expand this:

    I said as far as I know, there is no way, but then the kid said:

    f'(x^0.5)= ( (x+h)^0.5-x^0.5 ) / h = 0.5 x ^ -0.5;
    (x + h)^0.5 = h(0.5 x ^ -0.5) + x^0.5;

    and then, he proposed that x and h can be replaced by other variables, such as a and b, and the reason why the equation (a + b)^0.5 = b(0.5 a ^ -0.5) + a^0.5 is false is because h in the original equation approximated zero, and any term with h in it at the original derivative is removed, therefore, the "actual" way (a+b)^0.5 should be expanded is:

    b(0.5 a ^ -0.5) + a^0.5 + c; where c is a series of functions in terms of a and b

    I suspect that some of his logic is fallacious when doing the algebra to the derivative, because the equality is only true with h-->0, then again I am not very far into the logic of maths myself, so is there a way to demonstrate that this is wrong? I know the general formula for binomial expansion with integer exponents, but I don't have the proof, so maybe that will help if you can give it to me too.
  2. jcsd
  3. Nov 5, 2015 #2


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    There are two errors in the first line. The first one, which you identified, is that the limit as ##h\to 0## has not been taken, and the equation does not hold if the limit is not taken.

    Secondly ##\frac{(x+h)^{0.5}-x^{0.5}}{h}\neq 0.5x^{0.5}##.

    I suggest you ask him to justify his reasoning to you by working through the steps above one at a time. Working through and finding his own errors will be a more useful experience than having somebody else point them out for him.

    One could use a Taylor series to expand the formula, but if he's just starting calculus then Taylor series may be a bit too advanced.
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook