How can I solve this integral using integration by parts?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jacy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Dx Integrate
AI Thread Summary
The integral x^2 sin(x^2) dx does not have an elementary antiderivative, which led to confusion among participants. The problem was initially presented as part of an exam, but it was later clarified by the teacher that it contained a typo and should have been x^2 sin^2(x). Participants discussed the potential for using integration by parts, but ultimately concluded that the original problem was unsolvable in elementary terms. The discussion highlighted the importance of accurately presenting mathematical problems to avoid confusion. The corrected problem can be evaluated using integration by parts.
jacy
Messages
76
Reaction score
0
Hi ,
I am having trouble integrating this problem.

Integrate x^2 sin(x^2) dx

Here is what i did. I used the substitution method.

u = x^2 sqrt u = x
du = 2x dx
du/2x = dx

du/2 sqrt u = dx since sqrt u = x

substituting this in the equation

u sin(u) du/2 sqrt u

Now i don't know how to integrate this. Please help, thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
jacy said:
Hi ,
I am having trouble integrating this problem.

Integrate x^2 sin(x^2) dx

I don't think the antiderivative of your integrand is an elementary...but I don't really know for sure.
 
I believe you're correct. My computer cannot calculate it.
 
apmcavoy said:
I believe you're correct. My computer cannot calculate it.


Thanks 4 ur time. Do u think that problem is wrong.
 
jacy said:
Thanks 4 ur time. Do u think that problem is wrong.

The problem is fine...it's just that you cannot find an elementary antiderivative as a solution.
 
where'd you obtain the problem?
 
It would work if the integrand was x\sin{x^{2}}.
 
GCT said:
where'd you obtain the problem?

Thanks for looking at the problem. My teacher gave this problem on the exam. How can we solve this.
 
Integration by parts might be possible, but my computer and my TI 89 cannot compute it, so there's probably not a simple antiderivative. And you were given this problem on a test? :bugeye:
 
  • #10
Tony11235 said:
Integration by parts might be possible, but my computer and my TI 89 cannot compute it, so there's probably not a simple antiderivative. And you were given this problem on a test? :bugeye:

Thanks, do u think the substitution method that i used will work. This wasn't the only one there were 3 more.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Are you sure it wasn't asking you to evaluate it as a definite integral numerically? That's the only way I can see doing this.
 
  • #12
apmcavoy said:
Are you sure it wasn't asking you to evaluate it as a definite integral numerically? That's the only way I can see doing this.

No it isn't a definite integral. It's tough one. Hopefully the teacher should provide the solution today. If he does, then can i post the solution in here, thanks.
 
  • #13
\int x^2\sin(x^2) dx [/tex]<br /> <br /> \int x^2\sin(x^2) dx = \frac{-x}{2}\cos(x^2) + \frac{1}{2} \int \cos(x^2) dx [/tex]
 
  • #14
whozum said:
\int x^2\sin(x^2) dx [/tex]<br /> <br /> \int x^2\sin(x^2) dx = \frac{-x}{2}\cos(x^2) + \frac{1}{2} \int \cos(x^2) dx [/tex]
&lt;br /&gt; &lt;br /&gt; True, but now what&amp;#039;s \frac{1}{2} \int \cos(x^2) dx?&lt;br /&gt; &lt;br /&gt; jacy, the initial response you received was correct. Your integrand doesn&amp;#039;t have an elementary antiderivative. 10 bucks says that the problem was supposed to be \int x\sin(x^2) dx.
 
  • #15
Tom Mattson said:
True, but now what's \frac{1}{2} \int \cos(x^2) dx?

jacy, the initial response you received was correct. Your integrand doesn't have an elementary antiderivative. 10 bucks says that the problem was supposed to be \int x\sin(x^2) dx.

Its not elementary i was just trying it out and seeing how far I could get, but figured I'd just post it anyway.
 
  • #16
Here's the answer from Mathematica in case anyone was wondering. I agree, it was probably supposed to be \int x\sin{(x^2)}dx.
 

Attachments

  • Integrate.gif
    Integrate.gif
    1.4 KB · Views: 623
  • #17
Tom Mattson said:
True, but now what's \frac{1}{2} \int \cos(x^2) dx?

jacy, the initial response you received was correct. Your integrand doesn't have an elementary antiderivative. 10 bucks says that the problem was supposed to be \int x\sin(x^2) dx.

I don't think so it was a typo. This problem was on the exam, thanks.
 
  • #18
jacy said:
I don't think so it was a typo. This problem was on the exam, thanks.

Was the problem asking to find the derivative of that function?
 
  • #19
whozum said:
Was the problem asking to find the derivative of that function?

We have to find the anti derivative of that function. Today the teacher said that he made a typo it should be
integrate x^2 sin^2(x) instead of x^2 sin(x^2)

How did u guys type the sign of integral
 
  • #20
\int {x^2 \sin ^2 x\,dx}
can be evaluated via integration by parts.

jacy, the integral sign is just \int when using LaTeX.
Try clicking on this integral sign: \int
 
  • #21
bomba923 said:
\int {x^2 \sin ^2 x\,dx}
can be evaluated via integration by parts.

jacy, the integral sign is just \int when using LaTeX.
Try clicking on this integral sign: \int

Thanks, yea now i can solve it
 
Back
Top