Cato
- 56
- 10
Electrons and positrons are assumed to be point masses. Two points presumably can never actually touch. How close do they have to be before they annihilate each other?
The discussion revolves around the conditions necessary for electrons and positrons to interact and annihilate each other. It explores theoretical aspects of particle interactions, conservation laws, and the implications of particle size and effective cross sections in different contexts.
Participants express differing views on the nature of particle size and the conditions for annihilation, indicating that multiple competing perspectives remain without consensus.
The discussion highlights limitations in defining particle size and the complexities involved in calculating probabilities for annihilation events, which depend on various factors including energy and state representation.
Cato said:Electrons and positrons are assumed to be point masses.
Cato said:How close do they have to be before they annihilate each other?
Quantum9999 said:In annihilation, the positron and electron collide head on moving at the same speed.
The standard scattering matrix elements give the probability density that an electron and a positron in a plane wave (thus delocalized with precise momentum but completely uncertain position) annihilate. This translates into a decay rate for streams of colliding pairs in two beams. For other states (strictly speaking also for beams - using the paraxial approximation) one has to take the appropriate superposition of momentum states to calculate the probability. Since there are no normalizable position states, there will always be some nonlocality (lack of precise position).Cato said:How close do they have to be before they annihilate each other?