How do electrolytes conduct electricity without redox?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lim23472
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electricity Redox
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the behavior of ions in saltwater when subjected to an electric voltage between two electrodes. It highlights that Na+ ions move towards the negative electrode while Cl- ions move towards the positive electrode. The conversation raises a critical question about the flow of current in the absence of redox reactions, suggesting that without these reactions, ions would accumulate at the electrodes, potentially halting current flow. It is clarified that direct current (DC) requires redox reactions for continued flow, as oxidation and reduction must occur at the electrodes. In contrast, alternating current (AC) can maintain conductivity in electrolytes without redox reactions, as it operates at various frequencies and uses specially designed electrodes and cells. The discussion also touches on the theoretical possibility of solvated electrons passing through the phase boundary without redox reactions, referencing alkali metals in liquid ammonia, but acknowledges the challenges of experimental verification due to departmental politics and differing research focuses.
lim23472
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Say you have salt water. If you apply an voltage between two electrodes Na+ ions will drift towards the negative electrode and Cl- ions towards the positive electrode. If a redox reaction happens at the electrodes, the ions transfer electrons to the electrodes and current continues to flow until all the ions are reduced/oxidized. Now what happens if there are no redox reactions? Wouldn't the ions just accumulate at the electrodes, eventually screening out the potential and therefore the current would stop flowing? If that's the case how do ppl measure the conductivity of electrolytes? It seems Kohlrausch's law says current will flow even if there is no redox, how is this possible? Or is it only possible to have AC current in such situations?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
lim23472 said:
therefore the current would stop flowing?
Just like an electrolytic capacitor.
lim23472 said:
how do ppl measure the conductivity of electrolytes?
With AC, at a variety of frequencies, between very carefully constructed and treated electrodes, in very carefully designed and maintained cells, under threat of severe mutilation by graduate advisors.
 
Bystander said:
Just like an electrolytic capacitor.

With AC, at a variety of frequencies, between very carefully constructed and treated electrodes, in very carefully designed and maintained cells, under threat of severe mutilation by graduate advisors.

So from the previous two answers, its correct to say that DC current would not flow in an electrolyte without redox?
 
DC current flow in an electrolyte solution requires reduction of species at the cell cathode and/or oxidation of some other species at the cell anode. Yes.
 
Please treat current in the bulk of the electrolyte separate from the charge transfer through the phase boundary.

Imagine a long copper wire, and imagine you have access to only part of it. You can easily check if there is current flowing through the wire, not bothering about how the circuit is closed. It is not different if you observe a volume of the solution.

In other words - you need a redox reaction to close the circuit (unless you don't*), but you don't need to see whole circuit to observe the current in the solution.

*I wonder if it is possible for the solvated electrons to pass directly through the phase boundary, without a redox reaction. Think alkali metals dissolved in liquid ammonia.
 
Borek said:
*I wonder if it is possible for the solvated electrons to pass directly through the phase boundary, without a redox reaction. Think alkali metals dissolved in liquid ammonia.
I could not talk the organickers and p-chem faculty into cooperating on that --- department politics, turf wars. "Not going to have a buncha fussy measurement types in my lab igniting all the solvent fumes," vs. "Not going to have a buncha slovenly organickers making a mess in my lab and corroding all my equipment."
 
I doubt is wasn't checked.
 
Borek said:
I doubt is wasn't checked.
This was talk among mods?
 
I mean: it would be surprising if the properties of solvated electron were not already researched and published.
 
Back
Top