How do I solve a trig equation with two functions on one side?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hypochondriac
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Trig
AI Thread Summary
To solve the equation 2sinx = cos(x-60) for 0<=x<=360, the user expanded the cosine term but initially made an error in multiplying both sides. After correcting to (4 - sqrt3)sinx = cosx, the discussion highlighted the importance of not dividing through by cos(x) to avoid losing solutions. It was clarified that using the tangent function can help find solutions without losing any, leading to the principal value of arctan(1/(4-sqrt(3))) and its periodic solution. The final solutions were determined to be approximately 23.8 and 203.8 degrees. The conversation emphasized that squaring both sides could introduce extraneous roots, making the tangent method preferable.
Hypochondriac
Messages
35
Reaction score
0
I have to solve:

2sinx = cos(x-60), for 0<=x<=360

so far i expanded the cos part

2sinx = cosxcos60 + sinxsin60

as cos60 = 1/2 and sin60 = (sqrt3)/2

2sinx = (1/2)cosx + ((sqrt3)/2)sinx

sinx = cosx + sqrt3 sinx

(1-sqrt3)sinx = cosx

but here's where I'm stuck, i have 2 trig functions in one equation and therefore cannot solve.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hypochondriac said:
I have to solve:

2sinx = cos(x-60), for 0<=x<=360

so far i expanded the cos part

2sinx = cosxcos60 + sinxsin60

as cos60 = 1/2 and sin60 = (sqrt3)/2

2sinx = (1/2)cosx + ((sqrt3)/2)sinx

sinx = cosx + sqrt3 sinx
This line is incorrect. You have multiplied both sides by 2 to remove the factor of 1/2 on the right hand side, so the left hand side should be premultipled by 4.
 
ahh yes, how silly of me,

but even now i have:

(4 - sqrt3)sinx = cosx

i need it all in sins or cos'
 
Hypochondriac said:
i need it all in sins or cos'

Or, you could remember that tanx=sinx/cosx
 
but if i divide through by cosx, i'll loose that solution of x because the cos' will cancel, its an equation not an expression.
 
No you won't. There's only going to be one solution to that equation in the range specified.
 
the answer in the back of the textbook gave 2 solutions.
I was told to never divide through with an equation, only with an expression

perhaps you only got one solution because you divided through to solve.
 
Last edited:
Hypochondriac said:
perhaps you only got one solution because you divided through to solve.

Sorry, I am being really stupid! You don't lose a solution by dividing by cos(x), but of course the function tan(x)= 1/(4-sqrt(3)), is periodic with period 180 degrees. So, the solutions to this in the given range will be the principal value for arctan(1/(4-sqrt(3))) [the one given by your calculator], and this value with 180 added on.
 
ok so arctan 1/(4-sqrt3) gives me my principle 23.8, and then +180 to give 203.8, my secondary.

Solved!
cheers, I am a bit weary about dividing through but I am not going to argue with the outcome!
 
  • #10
It's fine because you know that an x where cos(x) is zero can't possibly be a solution (otherwise you have 4 - sqrt(3) = 0).
 
  • #11
If you really wanted to, when you had sin on one side and cos on the other side, you could square both sides (and possibly introduce extraneous roots), and use an identity for (sinx)^2 or (cosx)^2, changing it to a quadratic type. The method above is much easier.
 
Back
Top