How do we know how much hydrogen the sun has?

In summary: N m/s, C V/s, etc.In summary, the estimate that the sun will run out of hydrogen in 4.5 to 5 billion years is based on the mass and wattage of the sun. The calculations take into account the percentage of hydrogen and helium in the sun's outer layers, the temperature and density of the core, and the rate at which the sun is using up hydrogen. This estimate is for the red giant stage, when the core becomes depleted of hydrogen and starts fusing helium, causing the sun to expand and eventually engulf the inner planets. The wattage of the sun is approximately 3.8E26 watts, which can be measured directly using a solar cell or calculated using the black-body
  • #1
ranger
Gold Member
1,687
2
I've been hearing these talks that the sun will run out of hydrogen in 4.5 to 5 billion years from now. My question is, how did we arrive at this estimate. Is it based on the mass or something? It would be good if you can show me the mathematical calculations.

--thanks.
 
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
ranger said:
I've been hearing these talks that the sun will run out of hydrogen in 4.5 to 5 billion years from now. My question is, how did we arrive at this estimate. Is it based on the mass or something? It would be good if you can show me the mathematical calculations.

--thanks.

this is not a cosmology question, it belongs more in general astronomy, or in astrophysics (the physics of stars)----but not to worry, ranger. the mods can easily move this thread into the appropriate subforum.

you are right that estimates of the remaining lifetime of the sun are based on mass.

we can easily tell the mass of the sun---it is about 2.0E30 kilograms
is it OK to write 2.0E30 instead of 2.0 x 1030?

and we can easily tell the wattage of the sun---it is about 3.8E26 watts.

we can tell the chemical make-up of the sun's outer layers by the spectral colors (different elements make different spectral lines) and the make-up is around 71 percent H and 26.5 percent He.

to a good approximation that percentage mix of H and He would also have been the ORIGINAL percentage mix the sun had when it condensed from gas.

I won't try to give you a complete answer. There are plenty of experts around who can do that. But I will just give a few hints for starters. The terminal event we are usually talking about is the RED GIANT stage which happens when the CORE (the central 10 percent or so, where it is hot and dense enough for fusion to occur) becomes DEPLETED OF HYDROGEN, so that the core no longer primarily fuses hydrogen and becomes crushed to a higher density and pressure where it starts to fuse HELIUM. this helium-fusing stage is associated with the enormous expansion of the star, forming what is called a "red giant". A star keeps doing stuff for millions of years after red giant, but that's the end as far as we are concerned because it doesn't support life on the inner planets.

So the question becomes, at the rate the sun is putting out energy (3.8E26 watts) how fast is it using up the hydrogen in its core? and how soon does the core become so depleted of hydrogen that it has to start fusing helium?

just as interesting trivia, the temperature in the core is 15 million kelvin,
and the density is 160 times that of water-----those are good conditions for fusion.

at the SURFACE of the sun it is no more than about 6000 kelvin, which is nothing compared with 15 million down in the core. Fusion is not going to happen except where it is really hot (the central 10 percent or so).

the sun as a whole is not going to "run out" of hydrogen, the outer layers will still be rich in hydrogen even when it goes red giant and expands to roast or engulf the inner planets.

Good luck, keep asking questions, you will probably get someone with expertise to provide formulas and stuff :smile:
 
Last edited:
  • #3
I see that you mentioned the wattage of the sun several times. How did you get this? I'm assuming that the surface temperature and the area influence this? You also mentioned this figure, 3.8E26 for the wattage. What unit of time is it, mayb output per second?

thanks again.
 
  • #4
You can measure the wattage directly with a solar cell: Divide the wattage you get from the cell by the cell's overall efficiency and multiply by the area of a sphere the size of Earth's orbit (not sure how much the atmosphere absorbs, but it'll get you a good start. That should get you reasonably close. Or you can use the black-body radiation equation to calculate it.

And watts is a time-based unit: J/s
 
Last edited:

1. How do we know how much hydrogen the sun has?

Scientists use a variety of methods to determine the amount of hydrogen in the sun. One method is through spectroscopy, which analyzes the light emitted by the sun and identifies the specific elements present. Another method is through helioseismology, which studies the vibrations on the surface of the sun to determine its internal structure and composition.

2. Can we physically measure the amount of hydrogen in the sun?

No, it is not possible to directly measure the amount of hydrogen in the sun. However, scientists can estimate the amount based on the sun's mass and its known composition of 70% hydrogen. This calculation is supported by various observational data and models of the sun's structure.

3. How do we know that the sun is mostly made up of hydrogen?

Scientists have studied the light and radiation emitted by the sun and have found that the majority of it consists of hydrogen. This is also supported by the fact that hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe and is a key component in the formation of stars.

4. Has the amount of hydrogen in the sun changed over time?

It is believed that the amount of hydrogen in the sun has remained relatively constant throughout its lifetime. The sun is in a state of equilibrium, where the amount of energy produced by nuclear fusion reactions is balanced by the amount of energy released into space. This suggests that the amount of hydrogen in the sun has not significantly increased or decreased over time.

5. Why is it important to know the amount of hydrogen in the sun?

Understanding the amount of hydrogen in the sun is crucial for understanding the sun's energy production and its impact on the solar system. It also helps scientists make predictions about the future behavior of the sun and its potential effects on Earth and other planets.

Similar threads

  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
26
Views
5K
Replies
28
Views
4K
  • Cosmology
Replies
14
Views
2K
Back
Top