Engineering How Do You Analyze a PV Diagram for a Multi-Step Gas Process?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on analyzing a PV diagram for a multi-step gas process involving a two-atom gas with gamma = 7/5. Participants discuss the steps of the process, including isobaric expansion, adiabatic expansion, and compression, while seeking equations for the adiabatic path and a parabolic compression curve. Key equations for isobaric and adiabatic processes are mentioned, with emphasis on calculating constants and solving for unknowns. The conversation highlights the need for accurate plotting of pressure and volume on the diagram and culminates in successfully completing the assignment with collaborative assistance. Overall, the thread illustrates the challenges and solutions in understanding thermodynamic processes.
aspic
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
A circuit process?

A gas consisting of two atoms have gamma = 7/5. It is used as "worksubstance" for the following steps:
I: Isobar expansion from V1 = 1.00m3 to V2 = 2.00m3 with P1 = 3.00*105Pa
II: adiabatic expansion to (P3, V3), and
III: compression back to (P1,V1), as a parabola with bottompoint where (Pmin = 1.00*105 Pa, and V= V2 = 2.00m3)

First of all: draw the "circuit" in a PV-diagram. (I use circuit in lack of a better word, suggestions?) :) This goes okey, and then: Find an equation for the "adiabatic" in step II, and for the parabola in step III. Then find the volume V3 and the pressure P3.

I can't get past this point.. Excuse my poor english, as this assignment is given in a different language and I therefore had to translate it :) Shout if there are things you don't understand.

2. Homework Equations :
For isobar process: W = p(V2 - V1) and for abdiatic processes: P1*V1gamma = P2*V2gamma, is this all I really need?

3. The Attempt at a Solution :

My attempt is really poor really. I've painted a quick scetch of the diagram, and it is attached to the thread. My guesses is that the work W < 0 in II and III, and W > 0 in I?

I really don't know how to find the equations for the abdiatic, or the parabola. My guesses is that I should end up with two equations with V3 and P3 as unknowns, and solve.

It would be really helpful if you could at least point me in the right direction! :)
 

Attachments

  • test.JPG
    test.JPG
    4.1 KB · Views: 408
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF :smile:

aspic said:
A circuit process?
First of all: draw the "circuit" in a PV-diagram. (I use circuit in lack of a better word, suggestions?)
In English, "cycle" is the term usually used.

2. Homework Equations :
For isobar process: W = p(V2 - V1) and for abdiatic processes: P1*V1gamma = P2*V2gamma, is this all I really need?
Almost.

The adiabatic path does not actually contain the point (V1,P1) as defined in the problem statement, so that equation needs to be modified. But you do have the right idea.

Also, you'll need the equation for the parabola. They tell you where it's minimum value is, and we also know it contains the point (V1,P1). You can use that information to find it's equation.
 
Thank you sir! :blushing: And how could I forget the word cycle, as it "fits" way better. :smile:

At the moment I'm focusing on the first problem (that really should be an easy nut to crack, but it got me stuck).

Let me rephrase the statemen then: I know that the abdiatic path gives pVgamma = constant, but how does this help me? I'm really intrigued that this gives me such a hard time..
 
You're welcome.
Since we know P=P1 and V=V2 at the beginning of the adiabatic path, we can calculate what the constant is in the equation

pVgamma = constant
 
So the constant equals 6.0*105, but how does this help me further? Should I set P3*V3gamma = "the constant"? But then I have an equation with two unknowns.

I really appreciate your help RedBelly :smile:
 
aspic said:
First of all: draw the "circuit" in a PV-diagram. (I use circuit in lack of a better word, suggestions?) :) This goes okey, and then: Find an equation for the "adiabatic" in step II, and for the parabola in step III. Then find the volume V3 and the pressure P3.

At this point, we're working on the 2nd question, "Find an equation for the adiabatic in step II". So don't worry about P3 and V3 yet, it's just P and V at this point.
 
Okey, with that in mind I'll try to solve problem two.

Equation for parabola: y = a(x - h)2 + k.
h and k are respectively the coordinates for the vertex, that gives:

y = a(x - Pmin)2 + V2.

Since the P1 and V1 is a point on the graph of the line it gives that:
V1 = a(P1 - Pmin)2 + V2.
This gives:

a = (V1 - V2)/(P1 - Pmin)2

Now that I have a, I can set up a similar equation for P3, V3, since it is a point on the line of the graph? Sorry for my messy maths, as I was on my way out the door :shy:

V3 = a(P3 - Pmin)2 + V2.
Edit: no, this can't be correct? After som trying and failing, when I substitute either V3, or P3 with p3*V3gamma = constant, I get a really really messy equation =/
 
Last edited:
aspic said:
Okey, with that in mind I'll try to solve problem two.

Equation for parabola: y = a(x - h)2 + k.
h and k are respectively the coordinates for the vertex, that gives:

y = a(x - Pmin)2 + V2.

We should be plotting P along the vertical y-axis, and V along the horizontal x-axis. You have P and V reversed.

Except for that, it looks like you have the right idea.
 
Well, I'm sorry that I'm reply'ing this late, but I just wanted to give this thread some closure. I managed to do the assignment (with your held Redbelly, and some other students help). After finding the equation for the parabola, we had to solve the equation with either Newtons Method or graphically. This assignment was pretty much over our head really :) But thanks for helping out!
 
  • #10
Glad it worked out :smile:
 
Back
Top