How Do You Calculate the Number of Microstates in Money Distribution?

  • Thread starter Thread starter toreil
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Money
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the number of microstates in distributing E dollars among N people, where each person can receive a maximum of 1 dollar and E is less than N. The solution approach involves using combinatorial methods to select a subset of size E from N individuals, as each person can either receive a dollar or not. There is a debate about interpreting the distribution in terms of dollars versus cents, with the latter suggesting that the distribution is more nuanced due to the constraints on dollar allocation. The conversation also touches on the theoretical implications of money distribution models, comparing them to Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac statistics. Ultimately, the interpretation of the problem and the method of calculation are crucial for arriving at the correct number of microstates.
toreil
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
I am studying for a statistical physics exam and have been struggling with the statistic parts, especially calculating the number of microstates. I am starting to understand most questions but have no clue how to handle this one.

Homework Statement



We distribute a total of E dollars among a population of N people. The rules are that each person can get a max of 1 dollar and that E < N, find the number of ways this can be done.

Homework Equations



?

The Attempt at a Solution



W = \frac{\left(E\times100\right)!}{100!\left(\left(E-1\right)\times100\right)!}\times p_{e} where p_{e} = \frac{E}{N} the average value received by each person
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
OK, so each person either does or does not get a dollar, and there are E dollars total.

Hmmm... so isn't this exactly the same as selecting a subset of size E from the N people?
 
As far as I'm aware because the question states that each person gets a maximum of 1 dollar the actual amount of money each person receives is counted in cents rather than dollars.
 
To me, "We distribute a total of E dollars" sounds like the unit of distribution is a dollar. But other interpretations are certainly possible.
 
toreil said:
As far as I'm aware because the question states that each person gets a maximum of 1 dollar the actual amount of money each person receives is counted in cents rather than dollars.

This would correspond to an unphysical situation in which Money is neither Bose-Einstein (person can have any number of dollars) or Fermi-Dirac (person can have either 1 dollar or none). Of course, money IS unphysical, so maybe the 100 cents interpretation is OK.

RGV
 
Back
Top