How do you define honor?

  • Thread starter drag
  • Start date
In summary, honor is defined as the feeling of dignity based on standards for achieving it, and can be both restraining and beneficial for change. Its importance lies in its ability to form a foundation of trust and good will for human life to flourish. It is both culture-dependent and universal for mankind, as it is directly dependent on culture but all cultures develop in ways that are universal to human nature.
  • #1

drag

Science Advisor
1,105
1
Greetings !

Honour:
How do you define it ?
What's your opinion about it ?
What is its importance ?
Do you think it's mostly universal
for mankind or mostly culture-dependent
(if that question is relevant to your view) ?
Other stuff you consider relevant.

Please, feel free NOT to discuss it unless
you really want to, I won't be offended !
So what ?! So I posted a thread on this !
So I wanted to know your opinion ! But...
Who cares ?!

Live long and prosper.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
How do you define it ?
Social kudos. A nice system created by society to generate an automatic hierarchy according to adherence to select codes of conduct. A evolved mechanism to discourage radicalism, and hence preserve stability.

What's your opinion about it ?
Erm... It just exists. In some ways it is restraining and bad for change, in others it preserves the state of the world and secures the rights of weaker people.

What is its importance ?
One part of honor is the way it forms a foundation to trust. Studies show that a world where you can form a reliable belief in trust and good will is one in which human life may flourish. A sense of honor and dignity, in some form or description, is mostly essential in this way.

Do you think it's mostly universal
for mankind or mostly culture-dependent
(if that question is relevant to your view) ?
Both. It's is directly culture-dependent, but indirectly all cultures develop in many ways that are universal to the nature of mankind.
 
  • #3


Interesting thread, drag.

Originally posted by drag
Honour:
How do you define it ?

I define it as the feeling of dignity, based on pre-supposed standards for achieving that dignity.

What's your opinion about it ?

There's nothing wrong with it (IMO), provided it doesn't impare one's judgement, and cause one to behave irrationally. Oh, wait a minute, that's exactly what it does!

Seriously, I think that it's fine, but is often taken to extremes, and is then just a way to feed one's ego, while still behaving stupidly.

What is its importance ?

Can't think of any, except that it helps one's self-esteem.

Do you think it's mostly universal
for mankind or mostly culture-dependent

I think it's dependent on personal opinion. Yes, often it is culture-dependent, and there is no universal standard for it, but I still think that one chooses how to attain honor.
 
  • #4
Died at war = honor. (Survived = not much).
 
  • #5
Greetings !

Hmm... pretty negative opinions, so far.
Mentat's perfectly right about the ego part.

How about honour suplementing compassion, for
the strong who consider compassion itself
to be a sign of weakness ?
Any other notable aspects you can think of ?

Live long and prosper.
 
  • #6
Mine wasn't exactly negative... I mean that it is socially useful to have such a concept, but we can't consider any sense of honor as somehow transcendent. I suggest that each society has it's own sense of honor system to provide that little boost to standing codes of conduct, and to assert it's own society's superiority. In a society which emphasises competition and stubborn determination, compassion can indeed be a matter of dishonor. (No doubt we all turn to Japan as an example here...)
 
  • #7
I think honor may be hard-wired...but the expression of it is cultural. For instance, there are people who completely think that it is honorable to lie, cheat, and steal, to achieve their goals. This, of course, is based on their supposed superiority.
 
  • #8
Originally posted by FZ+
(No doubt we all turn to Japan as an example here...)
Yip, that is exactly where my mind went, and I agreed with and liked the way you said the things you did.

It’s a ‘social thang’, loose face, commit seppuku, and everything returns to normal...
It was more of a dishonor to be a ronin than to be a samurai who lived by bushido, yet the ronin had more honor than skilled laborer who were still a notch above a peasant.

So, to save face, I will consider committing seppuku if Dubya looses the next election…NOT!
 
  • #9


Interesting...

Honour:
How do you define it ?
Not screwing over others for your own benefit. Ie. Selflessness, standing by your principles, and not caving into fear and other base urges. And other stuff like that.

What's your opinion about it ?
The amount of honourable behaviour in the world and the amount of warfare and other troubles are inversely proportionate.

What is its importance ?
See above.

Do you think it's mostly universal for mankind or mostly culture-dependent (if that question is relevant to your view) ?
There have been many definitions of honour through the ages, in different places. However, some conceptions of the term were truly whacky, such as the samurai being able to kill a peasant if the dude didn't bow low enough to gratify his stupid ego (there's a reason those feudal retards were overthorwn). To me, honour is based on logic, which really is a lengthy topic so I won't get into it here. But clear thinkers, it seems to me, no matter where or when they are from, will eventually reach certain unavoidable conclusions through logical deduction. This is why Socrates and Prince Siddhartha came to similar conclusions about humanity. In the end, apart from crazy cultural spasms such as we saw in various feudal cultures, "honour" (to me) is an absolute of human behaviour which can be reached in any time and place provided the people are capable of clear thought.
 

1. What is the definition of honor?

Honor is the quality of being honest, fair, and having a strong moral compass. It involves having integrity, keeping promises, and being respectful towards others.

2. How do you earn honor?

Honor is not something that can be earned, it is a personal trait that is developed through one's actions and choices. It is earned by consistently behaving in an honorable manner.

3. Can honor be taught?

While honor is often instilled in individuals from a young age through teachings and role models, it is ultimately up to the individual to embrace and develop this trait on their own.

4. Is honor subjective?

While the concept of honor may vary slightly across cultures and individuals, the basic principles of honesty, fairness, and respect are universally accepted as honorable traits.

5. How does honor affect society?

Honor plays a crucial role in society as it promotes trust, respect, and cooperation among individuals. A society that values honor is likely to have stronger relationships and a more positive community. On the other hand, a lack of honor can lead to dishonesty, conflict, and a breakdown of societal norms.

Back
Top