How Does Earthing Affect Charge Distribution on Spherical Shells?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the charge distribution on three concentric spherical shells, where shell B is earthed and shells A and C have charges q and -q, respectively. It is clarified that shell B, being grounded, can draw charges from the ground, allowing it to have a non-zero net charge despite initially having none. The inner surface of shell B acquires a charge of -q, while the outer surface has a charge q', leading to a corresponding charge distribution on shell C to maintain charge conservation. The conversation also emphasizes that while shell B is not isolated due to its grounding, shells A and C are isolated, allowing charge conservation to apply to them. Overall, the grounding of shell B complicates the application of charge conservation principles in this scenario.
  • #51
gracy said:
r.Hence,charges migrate from cavity but field stays.
But according to the following video

charge +q stays in the metal cavity .
gracy said:
Does it mean whenever I will find such problem when there is not single earthed shell ,I'll assume some charge on it's surface later with the help of potentials ,I will find how much charge B must have to be at zero potential?

How do we know that outer surface of B would have positiv charge i.ewhy not we assumed -q' instead of q'?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
gracy said:
How do we know that outer surface of B would have positive charge i.e.why not we assumed -q' instead of q'?
I believe it is because the net field inside the thickness of shell B must be 0 since it is a metal.
 
  • #53
gracy said:
How do we know that outer surface of B would have positiv charge i.ewhy not we assumed -q' instead of q'
The video itself explains why very clearly. What does the video say?
 
  • #54
gracy said:
How do we know that outer surface of B would have positiv charge i.ewhy not we assumed -q' instead of q'?
It is not from the video.It is fro my OP.
 
  • #55
Then why did you bring in the video at all? Honestly gracy, that is irritating.

Thread closed. Please spend more time on your own before posting and then put some additional effort into making clear and focused threads.
 
Back
Top