How Does the Brain-Mind Relationship Shape Our Understanding of Consciousness?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Poorichard2
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Relationship
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the relationship between the brain and the mind, likening the brain to hardware and the mind to software. The brain has a tangible physical presence, while the mind's exact location and nature within the brain remain uncertain. Scientific evidence suggests that while the mind can function independently of certain bodily injuries, it ceases to exist if the brain is damaged or destroyed, indicating a strong connection between the two. The conversation raises questions about whether the mind can exist without the physical brain and vice versa, leaning towards the idea that they function as a unit. The mind may not be merely "in" the brain but could be a process influenced by both brain activity and bodily interactions. The exchange also touches on sensory perception and the transmission of information to the brain, emphasizing the complexity of understanding the mind's dimensional perception and self-awareness. Further exploration of these concepts is encouraged, inviting feedback from others interested in the topic.
Poorichard2
Messages
39
Reaction score
0
I find it difficult on knowing where to begin, brain or mind. In a lecture I attended
the speaker said the brain can be thought of as the hardware and the mind as
the software. After much thought on this I was comfortable with the idea,it seem
to fit so well but not totally. The brain as we know has physical substance,shape
texture and fluid. The mind we believe is somewhere in the brain but uncertain
the space or state of it's existence. We do understand through science that the
mind is somewhere in the brain, as an example: if an arm is removed,leg or other
parts of the body is damaged except the brain, mind continues to function, but on
the other hand the brain is damged or destroyed mind ceases, thus we assume a
relationship of brain and mind. Let's assume that the mind is the seat of the brain's
reality (software) and the brain's physical geography the hardware or structure.
There seems to be a relationship of brain development and the mind's capacity,
and a relationship of mind to the brain's capacity, however from different perspectives.
Can mind exist without the physical envelope of a wet brain? Can the wet brain exist
without mind? I am more or less inclined to think of brain and mind as a unit, the
wet brain as the housing and the mind as it's rational reality.
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
Originally posted by Poorichard2
I find it difficult on knowing where to begin, brain or mind. In a lecture I attended
the speaker said the brain can be thought of as the hardware and the mind as
the software. After much thought on this I was comfortable with the idea,it seem
to fit so well but not totally. The brain as we know has physical substance,shape
texture and fluid. The mind we believe is somewhere in the brain but uncertain
the space or state of it's existence. We do understand through science that the
mind is somewhere in the brain, as an example: if an arm is removed,leg or other
parts of the body is damaged except the brain, mind continues to function, but on
the other hand the brain is damged or destroyed mind ceases, thus we assume a
relationship of brain and mind. Let's assume that the mind is the seat of the brain's
reality (software) and the brain's physical geography the hardware or structure.
There seems to be a relationship of brain development and the mind's capacity,
and a relationship of mind to the brain's capacity, however from different perspectives.
Can mind exist without the physical envelope of a wet brain? Can the wet brain exist
without mind? I am more or less inclined to think of brain and mind as a unit, the
wet brain as the housing and the mind as it's rational reality.

Importantly, if the brain is injured in certain ways, the mind is affected in certain definite ways, and by studying people whose brains have been damaged in various very particular ways, we can get some insights into the way the brain and the mind are interelated. It seems to be wrong to think of the mind as being "in the brain" as if it were a thing someplace inside there. Perhaps the mind is a process which is determined partly by the physical processs in the brain and partly to the relations between the brain and the rest of the body.
 
Thank you for your response,I do appreciate it.
 
To continue on brain/mind/?

We know when looking at a person as an example, that image is beening realizied
within the brain, or hearing receiving vibrations, smell & taste stimulation,etc,etc.
The human body transmitting information to the brain,the brain in turn responding
to stimuli if it requires a response and so on. This elementary subject can easily
be found in book stores or the internet, the reason I mentioned it briefly is to
provide a back ground.
Information is not easily provided in certain areas unless expressed with theories
and or concepts, i.e. mind dimensional preception of self awareness,etc.etc.
which I have been working on for some years. These are the discussions in later
post I wish to continue with hope of feedback from others who are interested
on the subject. If no feed back I will just have to drop the subject here and
continue it on other posts.:smile:
 
Thread 'ChatGPT Examples, Good and Bad'
I've been experimenting with ChatGPT. Some results are good, some very very bad. I think examples can help expose the properties of this AI. Maybe you can post some of your favorite examples and tell us what they reveal about the properties of this AI. (I had problems with copy/paste of text and formatting, so I'm posting my examples as screen shots. That is a promising start. :smile: But then I provided values V=1, R1=1, R2=2, R3=3 and asked for the value of I. At first, it said...
Sorry if 'Profile Badge' is not the correct term. I have an MS 365 subscription and I've noticed on my Word documents the small circle with my initials in it is sometimes different in colour document to document (it's the circle at the top right of the doc, that, when you hover over it it tells you you're signed in; if you click on it you get a bit more info). Last night I had four docs with a red circle, one with blue. When I closed the blue and opened it again it was red. Today I have 3...
Back
Top