How does the Double-Slit Experiment explain the strange behavior of electrons?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the Double-Slit Experiment and the behavior of electrons, specifically addressing the misconception that electrons "know" when they are being observed. It clarifies that electrons do not switch between wave and particle states; rather, they exhibit properties of both depending on the experimental setup. The reduction of the interference pattern occurs when measurement is introduced, affecting the outcome without implying that the electron changes its fundamental nature. Participants share resources to enhance understanding, emphasizing that the behavior of electrons is consistent with quantum mechanics principles. Overall, the conversation aims to demystify the strange behavior of electrons in observational contexts.
Krushnaraj Pandya
Gold Member
Messages
697
Reaction score
73
Homework Statement
I have always seen YouTube videos saying how an electron 'knows' when we are observing it but I always put that down to youtubers creating popular science (verging on science fiction) hype for more views. I suppose there is more science behind an electron behaving like a particle when we put a laser beam behind the slits to observe which slit the electron passed through and there must be more concrete evidence behind it to explain that. I do not see any explanations in my textbook and I am hoping all the knowledgeable people on PF can help me understand this seemingly bizarre phenomenon of an electron changing its behavior when we try to 'see' it. Thank you very much
Relevant Equations
N.A
I have always seen YouTube videos saying how an electron 'knows' when we are observing it but I always put that down to youtubers creating popular science (verging on science fiction) hype for more views. I suppose there is more science behind an electron behaving like a particle when we put a laser beam behind the slits to observe which slit the electron passed through and there must be more concrete evidence behind it to explain that. I do not see any explanations in my textbook and I am hoping all the knowledgeable people on PF can help me understand this seemingly bizarre phenomenon of an electron changing its behavior when we try to 'see' it. Thank you very much
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Long story short : "observed" means "messed with".
 
hmmm27 said:
Long story short : "observed" means "messed with".
I understand, but how does that translate to the physical result of the interference pattern being reduced to a normal one expected for particles?
 
Common misconception. The electron does not change behaviour between being a wave and being a particle. It is neither. It is an electron and it behaves as an electron, which is a quantum particle. Now, that behaviour has some properties that are reminiscent of properties of a classical wave and some that are reminiscent of a classical particles. Which of these that become apparent in your experiment depends on what experiment you are doing.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Likes sysprog and Krushnaraj Pandya
Krushnaraj Pandya said:
Homework Statement: I have always seen YouTube videos saying how an electron 'knows' when we are observing it but I always put that down to youtubers creating popular science (verging on science fiction) hype for more views. I suppose there is more science behind an electron behaving like a particle when we put a laser beam behind the slits to observe which slit the electron passed through and there must be more concrete evidence behind it to explain that. I do not see any explanations in my textbook and I am hoping all the knowledgeable people on PF can help me understand this seemingly bizarre phenomenon of an electron changing its behavior when we try to 'see' it. Thank you very much
Homework Equations: N.A

I have always seen YouTube videos saying how an electron 'knows' when we are observing it but I always put that down to youtubers creating popular science (verging on science fiction) hype for more views. I suppose there is more science behind an electron behaving like a particle when we put a laser beam behind the slits to observe which slit the electron passed through and there must be more concrete evidence behind it to explain that. I do not see any explanations in my textbook and I am hoping all the knowledgeable people on PF can help me understand this seemingly bizarre phenomenon of an electron changing its behavior when we try to 'see' it. Thank you very much

Try this. See Chapter 4:

http://physics.mq.edu.au/~jcresser/Phys304/Handouts/QuantumPhysicsNotes.pdf
 
Orodruin said:
Common misconception. The electron does not change behaviour between being a wave and being a particle. It is neither. It is an electron and it behaves as an electron, which is a quantum particle. Now, that behaviour has some properties that are reminiscent of properties of a classical wave and some that are reminiscent of a classical particles. Which of these that become apparent in your experiment depends on what experiment you are doing.
Thank you very much, I understand now
 
Back
Top