How does the expansion of space affect the direction of time?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the relationship between the expansion of space and the concept of time, particularly whether they are interconnected. It clarifies that while the expansion of space affects phenomena like redshift, it does not directly cause time dilation, which is observer-dependent. The role of mass and gravity in the expansion of the universe is acknowledged, with the cosmological constant also playing a significant part. The conversation touches on the philosophical question of whether time can exist without space and motion, noting that there is no consensus among physicists on this matter. Overall, the connection between time, space, and motion is emphasized, highlighting the complexity of these concepts in astrophysics.
Geordie Ross
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hi, I'm new to the forum, and didn't really know where else to ask some questions, and get good answers, I'm fairly poor at mathematics, and grammar, but I have a passion for physics, astrophysics and cosmology. I have some niggling ideas and hypothesis that I can't find answers for, and I hope I don't make myself look foolish, but Einstein said he "visualised" his ideas, and I had a... "visualisation", that the expansion of space, is somehow linked to "arrow of time", in the sense of one way direction of time in large scale, could it be directly linked to expansion? And could it be linked to time dilation? Or does mass have any effect on expansion?
I'd appreciate any response, and please correct any mistakes I've made.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Welcome to the forum.

Time dilation and expansion are not linked as per se. The expansion does not cause any time dilation. We do see how expansion affects the wavelength of light called redshift. However this is not the same as time dilation. Gravitational time dilation in terms of an overall average mass density isn't sufficient to cause dilation.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, I appreciate the reply.
Would mass and gravity have any affect on expansion? And does expansion relate in any way to time?
 
Mass and gravity does affect expansion, so does the vacuum energy called the cosmological constant. The relation between the two are used to determine the rate of expansion. Time is only a measurement in expansion and not directly related to a direct effect on expansion

this link is related and has some further information.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=688708
 
Also on time dilation, this is an observer dependant property. An outside observer will see the dilation and inside observer will see time flow normally
 
Thanks for the clarification.
One more questions, could time exist without space and motion?
 
Thats one question that has no clear consensus. There are models that say yes such as multiverse models. Others that say time started at the first moment of that space formed.

So I cannot give you a definitive answer
 
Mordred said:
Thats one question that has no clear consensus. There are models that say yes such as multiverse models. Others that say time started at the first moment of that space formed.

So I cannot give you a definitive answer

Some adhere to the Hawking theory - time being the product of our brains, simply. That there is no Newtonian "ticking clock" for the universe progression.

Could time truly exist without objects? What do current astrophysicist/astronomers have to say about this? Could you ever get indirect evidence for any viewpoint?
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Chronos said:
Time, space and motion are obviously connected. Gravity is also involved in this arrangement. See comments by Sten Odenwald at https://einstein.stanford.edu/content/relativity/a11332.html
What area would this be classified under in Astrophysics? That is; space, objects and motions?.. Not just the particles, and not just motion, but also space and time.

The link was quite interesting!
 
Back
Top