How fast will this torsion spring open a lid?

4 replies · 4K views · last reply
Prockey
Messages
3
Reaction score
2
TL;DR
Selection of a torsion spring to open a hinged lid
Hi,

I'm designing a small container with a spring loaded hollow rectangular lid. I want the lid to open when a button is pressed, so I have a torsion spring at the hinge. I want to know if the spring I selected is able to open the lid and also how long it would take to open 90°.

Below is a diagram of the hinge, spring and the center of gravity (COG) of the lid. The mass of the lid is 0.005 kg.
Diagram of a rectangular lid with a hinge and torsion spring at its lower-left corner, marked by a green dot, and a yellow dot for the center of gravity (COG). A dashed line joins them, labelled 22.6mm, with the angle between it and the lid's bottom edge marked as 33°.

This is what I have so far:
Torque needed to open lid:
Torque = weight * distance to COG * Cos(33)
= 0.005 kg * 9.8 m/s^2 * 0.0226 m * 0.8386
= 0.0009 Nm

I'm going to design a custom spring, but for the sake of this question let's assume this torsion spring from McMaster which has a max torque of 0.117 in-lbs (0.0132 Nm).
Product listing for a 302 stainless steel torsion spring, 90 degree left-hand wound, 0.16 inch OD, with a specification table and a 90 degree deflection angle diagram.


Question #1: Since this spring is able to provide 0.0132 Nm and I only need 0.0009 Nm, the spring should work. Is this correct?

I also want to know how fast the lid will open in seconds given this spring.
I'm getting the center of gravity MoI from CAD, which I think I need:
Inertia properties panel from CAD software, with tabs for Inertia/G, Inertia/O, Inertia/P, Inertia/Axis and Inertia/Axis System. Inertia Matrix/G values: Ixx 1.004e-006 kgxm2, Iyy 3.734e-007 kgxm2, Izz 9.371e-007 kgxm2, Ixy, Ixz and Iyz all 0 kgxm2. Principal Moments/G: M1 3.734e-007, M2 9.371e-007, M3 1.004e-006 kgxm2.


I know that: Torque = Moment of inertia * angular acceleration
So: Angular acceleration = Torque/MoI

Using the spring torque and the Z MoI:
Angular acceleration = 0.0132 Nm/9.371e-007kg*m2
= 14087 rad/s^2

Question #2: Is this correct? This 14087 rad/s^2 answer seems way too fast to me.
Question #3: How do I convert this angular acceleration to the number of seconds it will take the lid to open 90°? I would like it to open in less than 1 second.

Thank you for your time!
 
Last edited:
Welcome, Prokey. :cool:

What is holding the lid in place?
Is there friction or pressure difference between the lid and the opening it covers and between the lid and any surface during the trajectory?
Is the lid rotating with the arm?
How do you plan to stop or reduce the oscillation caused by the spring after the arm-lid assemblyreaches maximum acceleration?
 
Thanks for the reply, Lnewqban !

I added more details to my diagram. There is a simple button/clip mechanism opposite the hinge holding the lid down. There is no pressure difference or friction, the lid is not sealing in any way. The lid is part of a small handheld container and there is a "hard-stop" on the lower part of the housing to stop the lid from over rotating.

Two-panel schematic of a hinged lid: left panel labelled Closed shows COG 22.6mm from the hinge at 33 degrees, with a push point on the right; right panel labelled Open shows the lid rotated 90 degrees with a button or clip mechanism holding it closed.


The hinge and spring are a small version of this:
Photo of a small metal spring-loaded hinge with a coiled torsion spring at its centre, two pivot barrels and four mounting holes in a flat plate.
 
The correct moment of inertia is the MOI about the center of gravity (COG) plus M*R^2, where M is the mass and R is the distance from the hinge to the COG. Search parallel axis theorem to learn more.

Design constraints include:
1) Open in less than one second
2) Do not slam it into the end stop too hard

I suggest starting with a spring at zero torque when the COM is directly above the hinge. Then the spring will be twisted 57 degrees when the lid is closed. If I correctly interpret the McMaster-Carr specification, the spring torque at 57 degrees will be 57 / 90 * 0.117 in-lbs * 4.45 N/lb * 0.0254 m/in = 0.0087 N-m.

The torque for initial acceleration is the spring torque minus the torque to raise the lid against gravity, or 0.0087 - 0.0009 = 0.0078 N-m. Hinge friction will also subtract from the net torque for acceleration, but hinge friction is typically (not always) small enough to ignore.

The initial acceleration will decrease as the lid raises. The exact calculation in closed form would be a challenge because the horizontal distance from the hinge to the COM is a trig function. A numerical solution is a typical real world way to get a near exact lid opening time. Or you can do a rough calculation that just might meet your needs.

Rough calculation: The MOI about the hinge is about 3.5E-6 kg-m^2. The initial acceleration is approximately 0.0078 N-m / 3.5E-6 kg-m^2 = 2200 rad/sec^2. Just as D = 0.5 * a * t^2 for linear acceleration, theta = 0.5 * alpha * t^2 for angular acceleration. Theta is in radians, alpha is in rad/sec^2, and 57 degrees is 1.0 radians.

Solving for t, I get about 30 msec to open 57 degrees. Since the acceleration decreases to zero at that point, multiply by two to get 60 msec. Remember, this is a rough calculation. The remaining 33 degrees to the end stop is at constant velocity.

The lid will open with a bang and slam against the end stop. It will most likely break if opened too many times. I used approximate numbers to show how to do the calculation. Now it's your turn to use real numbers. Enjoy.
 
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: berkeman and Prockey
Thank you, this was the guidance I needed!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman and jrmichler