How good Feynman Lectures are ?

  • Thread starter welatiger
  • Start date
  • #1
welatiger
85
0
how good Feynman Lectures are ?
and if learn basic physics
what mathematical physics book should i learn to learn core course physics ?
Is Mathematical methods for physicists good enough ?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
jeffreydk
135
0
Halliday/Resnick Fundamentals of Physics is an excellent introductory text.
 
  • #3
chroot
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
10,275
40
Feynman's lectures are beautiful and inspiring; they're fun to read, and will give you a profound and deep understanding of many phenomena and techniques. I think anyone with a real interest in physics should own a copy.

Unfortunately, they are quite bad at teaching you to solve problems. If you need to learn to do physics, that is, to be able to ace a test or write a paper, you should avoid them.

- Warren
 
  • #4
mgb_phys
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,889
15
I'm not sure how readable the Feynman lectures are if you don't already have a physics degree? They do assume lot of maths knowledge.

(Can't check - my house is in storage somewhere)
 
  • #5
chroot
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
10,275
40
Well, they were intended to be the first two years of physics lectures given to incoming Caltech students (given alongside math, etc.). By that logic, readers are only supposed to need high-school math... but I agree that it presumes a great deal more sophistication than do, well, all other books aimed at that audience. :smile:

- Warren
 
  • #6
Howers
447
3
I personally found them overrated. At least the classical mechanics section that I actually read.

Sometimes he obscures the main point by his analogies.
 
  • #7
mgb_phys
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,889
15
They are an excellent set of books an often give a unique way of looking at or deriving well known bits of physics. Not my field but a lot of QM people love the 3rd volume.

Although even the authors are not sure it's a great intro text:

Regarding the Feynman lectures on physics (that eventually became the famous three volumes), David Goodstein and Gerry Neugebauer wrote, “Through the distant veil of memory, many of the students and faculty attending the lectures have said that having two years of physics with Feynman was the experience of a lifetime.
But that’s not how it seemed at the time. Many of the students dreaded the class, and as the course wore on, attendance by the registered students started dropping alarmingly. But at the same time, more and more faculty and graduate students started attending. The room stayed full, and Feynman may never have known he was losing some of his intended audience.

But even in Feynman’s view, his pedagogical endeavor did not succeed.
He wrote in the 1963 preface to the Lectures: ‘I don’t think I did very well by the students.’ Rereading the books, one sometimes seems to catch Feynman looking over his shoulder, not at his young audience, but directly at his colleagues, saying ‘Look at that! Look how I finessed that point! Wasn’t that clever?’ But even when he thought he was explaining things lucidly to freshmen or sophomores, it was not really they who were able to benefit most from what he was doing. It was his peers — scientists, physicists, and professors — who would be the main beneficiaries of his magnificent achievement, which was nothing less than to see physics through the fresh and dynamic perspective of Richard Feynman.”
 
  • #8
Daverz
1,001
74
Some people always feel the need to point out that the Feynman Lectures are not exam workbooks. They are, however, filled with insight, will introduce you to a lot of interesting physics, and are a pleasure to read.
 
  • #9
physicsnoob93
169
0
Feynman's book, I feel are more for reference, like an encyclopedia. But the best introductory textbook I have seen after using Serway, University Physics, Halliday resnick WALKER and Halliday Resnick KRANE is Halliday Resnick Krane. I repeat, KRANE. Walker sucks. University Physics is amazing too, buy Krane explains as much and its much more compact, with good problems and MCQ too.
 
  • #10
j93
191
2
I personally found them overrated. At least the classical mechanics section that I actually read.

Sometimes he obscures the main point by his analogies.

I would agree. It would also not be a good introductory book especially for quantum because it is not taught like the other books.
 
  • #11
Sound Of Wisdom
6
0
They are the best introduction for understanding, methods & techniques in thinking & formulating theories.
They are helpful as 1st step in understanding the concepts & philosophy of physics
But unfortunately, they aren't enough, there is no solved & unsolved problems
U'll not find the recent discoveries, Experiments & new techniques
"LHC, DarkMatter...etc" that u can read about them in Halliday for examples
 
  • #12
glueball8
344
1
In the book it says that the aim is for undergrads but it seems that its the grads that got most out of it. Its probably not for you.
 
  • #13
T.O.E Dream
219
0
How good are the feynman lectures to one who's self-studying, meaning going more advanced?
 
  • #14
thrill3rnit3
Gold Member
716
1
It's great for conceptual learning, not for problem solving.
 
  • #15
j93
191
2
The problem with them they are too much like a popular science book for physics, there is too much focus on qualitative features of physics. Its the quantitative aspects that differentiate a popular science book from a proper textbook.
 
  • #16
physicsnoob93
169
0
How good are the feynman lectures to one who's self-studying, meaning going more advanced?

You would be better off with a standard undergraduate text for "self-studying".
 
  • #17
thrill3rnit3
Gold Member
716
1
You would be better off with a standard undergraduate text for "self-studying".

He can read both "standard" undergraduate text and Feynman lectures at the same time to get the most out of them.
 

Suggested for: How good Feynman Lectures are ?

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
521
Replies
2
Views
423
Replies
7
Views
450
  • Last Post
Replies
14
Views
759
  • Last Post
Replies
21
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
911
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
369
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
Top