How hot might this 3 amp transformer get?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the thermal characteristics and design considerations of a transformer constructed using copper wire and an iron core, specifically focusing on how hot the transformer and its components might get under certain conditions. Participants explore theoretical aspects, practical implications, and design choices related to transformer efficiency, heat generation, and safety.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes a transformer setup using 18 gauge copper wire and an iron ring, questioning the heat generated in the iron core and copper windings.
  • Another participant mentions that enameled magnet wire can withstand temperatures of at least 100°C, depending on insulation class.
  • A participant argues that the properties of the iron ring are unknown, suggesting that it may not function effectively as a transformer core.
  • Concerns are raised about the adequacy of the transformer design, particularly regarding the number of windings and the potential for excessive current draw.
  • One participant expresses uncertainty about the heat distribution between the resistor and the transformer, seeking a general idea rather than precise calculations.
  • Another participant discusses the implications of changing the number of windings on inductance and current, suggesting that fewer turns would significantly affect primary impedance and heat generation.
  • One participant proposes using a resistor in series with the primary coil to limit current, questioning how this would affect voltage and transformer operation.
  • Another participant warns about the risks of using a solid iron core due to eddy currents, suggesting that laminated cores are preferable.
  • Some participants emphasize the importance of practical experience and suggest sourcing transformers from old equipment for better understanding.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the transformer design and its thermal behavior, with no consensus reached on the adequacy of the proposed setup or the expected heat generation. Multiple competing perspectives on transformer efficiency and safety considerations remain present throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations in their understanding of transformer design, including the effects of core size, winding count, and material properties on heat generation and efficiency. There are unresolved questions about the practical implications of the proposed designs and the specific thermal characteristics of the components involved.

stargazer193857
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
20 gauge copper wire is rated for 5 amps.
Suppose someone use 18 gauge copper wire and wraps it 60 times around one side of a 1 inch iron ring, with the two ends then connected to a plug.
A separate piece of copper wire wraps around the other side 20 times, and goes to a 13.3 Ohm resister.
So now this transformer has reduced voltage from 120 volts to 40 volts, and the 13.3 Ohm resister regulates the current to 3 amps.
Suppose the resister has a good heat sink on it and thus won't melt.

How hot will will the iron right and copper windings get?
Would using electrical tape to guarantee electrical insulation result in burnt electrical tape?
What do fully enclosed (no fan) 9 volt or 12 volt AC DC converters use to dissipate their heat? I'm guessing they use less than 3 amps, which dodges my real question. I notice computer power supplies, which use more current, have fans.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Magnet (enameled) wire should withstand at least 100°C with no problem. Generally, it depends on the class of insulation of the device:

unimountgraph.GIF
 
This is not possible to answer since we know nothing of the properties of the iron ring. I could take a single strand of 18 AWG iron wire and wrap it around to form a 'ring'. It is not much of a transformer core and will cause the primary in your transformer to appear as a short circuit.
 
On the input size, where there is 120V ac, there is a 10amp fuze in series with the 18 gauge copper wire and 60 windings.
The ring is solid iron, 5mm tall, square cross section, 30mm outer diameter, 20mm inner diameter, wrapped in one layer of electrical tape to prevent conduction between wires and ring.
On the converted side, which is 40v, there is a 13.3 Ohm resister, to produced 3 amps.

I don't need an exact temperature calculation, just a ball park of where most of the heat will be produced. I already know how to calculate the heat produced at the resister, just not the transformer. I'm guessing the transformer windings would give impedance, which is kind of like resistance.

1. Does it matter whether the transformer had 60 and 20 windings or 12 and 4 windings?
2. Without a fan, would the electrical tape likely melt/burn?
3. Where would more heat be produced? At the 13.3 Ohm resister on the transformed side, or at transformer?
4. Would the 13.3 Ohm resister on the converted size provide a load for the input side to control current on that side, or would the input side need its own resister?
 
Without doing the calculations I am going to ball-park not very hot since I am pretty sure the 10 amp fuse will blow. The core is not large enough with the number of turns you have on the primary. If you eliminated the secondary I think it would still blow. Google transformer design. I know in the past I have found some ball park formulas that guide you through some very basic transformer design.
-
Basic transformer design:
The core size and number of primary windings need to be large enough to prevent excessive current with no load.
-
The size of the wire in the windings needs to be large enough to prevent resistive losses. Also, the number of turns needs to be kept low enough to help prevent resistive losses. Do you see a tradeoff here?
-
Core size also comes into play when considering the load placed on the secondary. If the core is not large enough too much current drawn from the secondary will cause the core to go into magnetic saturation which will cause excessive current to be drawn from the primary.
-
These are some things I know about transformer design. I am by no means an expert. I know enough to know there is PLENTY I do not know.
 
Thank you for that second keyword, design; that got me some good Google results.

OK, so the transformer connects their voltages but not their currents. Loads must be in both loops. I have plenty of reading to do.
 
stargazer193857 said:
1. Does it matter whether the transformer had 60 and 20 windings or 12 and 4 windings?
Considerations regarding magnetizing current.All other things being equal, 5x less turns means aprox. 25x less inductivity, which means 25x smaller primary impedance, which means 25 more primary current, which means aprox. 25x more joule heat for winding and 625x more for the fuse ..
 
Last edited:
This thread is a reason why engineers often don't hire mathematicians, at least not mathematicians who don't also have a degree in engineering.
Still, this math guy wants his physics education.

Power (heat) = (V^2)/R. I just now realized it, and see you kind of posted it here too. Suppose instead of more coils, a 1000 ohm resister is put in series with the primary. That means maybe 1/8 amp in the primary, and 1.5W of heat in that resister, which is manageable.
1. Would the primary coil still have 120V? Would it still impart 40V to the secondary coil?
Would the fact that there is only 0.125A in the primary have any effect on the secondary's ability to have 3A?
My limited understanding of the equations says the secondary would have all the desired properties. My intuition highly questions the transformer's ability to pass any significant energy to secondary.
My aversion to all the coils is what if I tiny scratch shorts out the whole thing? Fewer coils and a resister means a gap between coils so that a scratch would be a non-issue.
 
stargazer193857 said:
Power (heat) = (V^2)/R. I just now realized it, and see you kind of posted it here too. Suppose instead of more coils, a 1000 ohm resister is put in series with the primary. That means maybe 1/8 amp in the primary, and 1.5W of heat in that resister, which is manageable.
1. Would the primary coil still have 120V? Would it still impart 40V to the secondary coil?
Notice in my sentence "All other things being equal". I was referring just to magnetizing current (no secondary load) which is problematic by itself in your design.
edit: And careful with words becouse you're obviously very ignorant.
 
Last edited:
  • #10
If you use just a lump of Iron as your core, you can expect the core to get hot due to Eddy Currents. All Iron core transformers are made with laminations to prevent this.
Just go out and buy a transformer or even a really made low voltage power supply. You can get low voltage PSUs that will supply several Amps (AC or DC) off the shelf for not much money - probably cheaper than actually buying a transformer.
You can also buy transformer kits along with the design parameters for a range of Primary and Secondary voltages. The suppliers of these kits have done all the sums for you and you can sleep easier at night, knowing that it was designed by someone who knows about these things. :)

The cheap alternative is to find a piece of old equipment that is clearly much higher power than you need and scrounge the transformer out of it.
 
  • #11
stargazer193857 said:
Suppose instead of more coils, a 1000 ohm resister is put in series with the primary. That means maybe 1/8 amp in the primary, and 1.5W of heat in that resister, which is manageable.
1. Would the primary coil still have 120V?
No. For what you have in mind, most of the voltage will be lost across that resistor.
Would it still impart 40V to the secondary coil?
For your transformer, no, nothing like 40V.
My aversion to all the coils is what if I tiny scratch shorts out the whole thing? Fewer coils and a resister means a gap between coils so that a scratch would be a non-issue.
[/size] There is nothing that replaces practical experience. I suggest that you rip apart an old transformer from some broken electronic gear to see exactly how it is constructed and wound. (If you scavenge from a discarded appliance, first short across the electrolytic capacitors to remove any residual charge using a screwdriver with an insulated handle. You hold the handle.)
BTW, it's spelled resistor[/color] http://thumbnails111.imagebam.com/37333/4d0696373324852.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
30
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
5K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
46K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K