How Much Energy Can Be Extracted from a Rotating Disk?

15 replies · 2K views · last reply
aladinlamp
Messages
44
Reaction score
1
As you can see, solid disk is rotating at steady angular speed, without any external force beeing applied.

If i stop it gradualy within 60 second, by applying some linear load, how many kWh can i extract from this moving object?

Screenshot of a physics simulation showing a yellow solid circular disk on a blue grid, with a dark wedge marking its rotation, and an info panel listing area 3.142 m², mass 1000 kg, moment of inertia 500 kgm², angular velocity -0.105 rad/s, and total energy +2.742 J.
 
mfb said:
At most the total kinetic energy. You just have to convert J to kWh.

If i double angular speed,it doubles angular momentum but but why it quadruples Kinetic energy ?

If i apply load in this case and slow down the wheel by 50%, it looses 75% of kinetic energy, so i think total amount of J which i can extract is more complex to determine or am i missing something?
Physics simulator screenshot of a uniform yellow disk on a blue grid, with a dark wedge marking rotation and an info panel listing moment of inertia 500 kg·m², angular velocity -0.209 rad/s, and rotational kinetic energy 10.966 J.
 
aladinlamp said:
If i double angular speed,it doubles angular momentum but but why it quadruples Kinetic energy ?
Because of how they are defined.
 
ok so in real life, to stop wheel in 60 seconds i need some load,
to stop wheel with double speed in 60 seconds, do i need double load or quadruple load ?

i would say , i need just double load

so what does this KE represent in real life?
 
aladinlamp said:
so what does this KE represent in real life?
This:
aladinlamp said:
how many kWh can i extract from this moving object?
 
Last edited:
my point is, to accelerate wheel from zero to some speed it takes 1 unit of J

to double the speed it takes another 1 unit of J

so 2 unit of J total, linear relationship, when it comes to power inputbut somehow power output, KE is not linear but exponencial ?
 
aladinlamp said:
my point is, to accelerate wheel from zero to some speed it takes 1 unit of J

to double the speed it takes another 1 unit of J

No, it takes additional 3J to double the speed that was achieved by 1J.
 
if i set torque to fixed value, to accelarate from zero to some speed it takes 1 unit of time, to accelarate to double speed from zero with same torque, it takes 2 units of time

so i see pretty linear input, not 1J vs 3J as you said
 
aladinlamp said:
so i see pretty linear input,
Input of what?
 
no its, not

but how do you calculate it in this case,

In rotational systems, power is the product of the torque τ and angular velocity ω,

Equation P(t) = τ · ω, with power P as a function of time t equal to torque τ times angular velocity ω.


this is linear relationship, just tell me how did you get your exponencial

is it sum of energies from zero to some speed vs sum of energies from some speed to double speed?
 
ok so according to this

if i rotate the wheel with some electric motor and measure electricity consumption
from zero to speed x ,it will take let's say 10 seconds and i will use let's say 1 kwh

during another 10 seconds i accelerate from x to 2x, and use additional 3 kwh ?

is this correct according to facts above?
 
aladinlamp said:
ok so according to this

if i rotate the wheel with some electric motor and measure electricity consumption
from zero to speed x ,it will take let's say 10 seconds and i will use let's say 1 kwh

during another 10 seconds i accelerate from x to 2x, and use additional 3 kwh ?

is this correct according to facts above?
Assuming 100% efficiency, yes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mfb