- #71
gracy
- 2,486
- 83
Sir,please say "yes" to my post #69.
The spherical shell theorem is a theorem. It always applies as long as its premises hold. They do hold in the case of large r.gracy said:I think the answer to my question in previous post is no.Because if spherical shell theorem were to be applicable in both cases then for bigger /larger r also the motion will be simple harmonic motion which is not the fact as depicted in my OP.Right?
Re-read post #60 and, in particular, the edit there.gracy said:Then why not in this case?
Yeah, yeah, I corrected myself but you were just too quick.gracy said:post 60?it's mine.
I was correct in thinking so!gracy said:Oh! I thought I understood the whole thing.
It seems intuitively obvious. But let me see if I can come up with a solid and understandable argument...gracy said:Ok.With all credits to you I now understand why in case of big r it will not be simple hatmonic motion but why it would be periodic anyway?
Oooooooooooooo!THAT'S WHAT YOU KEEP SAYING!jbriggs444 said:Who, me? I know nothing. Nothing. The commandant says that there is to be no fraternizing with the prisoners.