How Will Discoveries at CERN Influence Religious Perspectives on Cosmology?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a homework assignment exploring how discoveries at CERN, particularly from the Large Hadron Collider, may influence religious perspectives on cosmology. Participants express skepticism about the assignment's feasibility, noting that the main question regarding the impact of CERN's findings on various religions is speculative and cannot be definitively answered. They highlight that while some subquestions can be addressed with factual information, others rely heavily on conjecture about future discoveries and their implications. The conversation also critiques the relevance of the assignment, suggesting that it lacks a solid foundation in scientific inquiry. Overall, the thread emphasizes the challenges of linking scientific discoveries to religious interpretations without concrete evidence.
Hioj
Messages
16
Reaction score
2
This is a homework assignment, thus the category, although it may not look like many of the other posts in this part of the forum.

My assignment is to write a paper about Cern. I'd like to answer the following questions:

Main question:
How will Cern alter our understanding of the universe and how will the different religions in the world react to this?

Sub questions:
1. How is the Large Hadron Collider built? Provide an illustration of the apparatuses used and the physics involved.
2. How is Cern expected to alter our understanding of the universe? Will the present theories of the fundamental particles stick? What about the Higgs particle?
3. How does Christianity look at the universe and its creation (cosmology)?
4. Which consequences will a new scientific understanding of the universe have on Christianity?

Do you have any recommendations as to what literature I can read/watch/listen to to answer these questions?

So far these are the sites I've been able to find:
http://public.web.cern.ch/public/en/LHC/LHC-en.html"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Hadron_Collider"

Thanks for all your help!

-Hioj
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
I will not provide you with guidance about what to "read/watch/listen" because I believe that there is plenty out there and undoubtedly you will apply your own filter to what you find. What I find troubling about this assignment is the plethora of speculation that it invites you to engage in. In other words, you can (mostly) make something up and nobody will be any wiser unless you say what people don't wish to hear.

The main question cannot be answered. We don't know what the LHC will (or will not) discover; that's why it was built, to see what it will (or will not) discover. Also, how "different religions in the world" will react to this is purely in the realm of speculation especially when we don't know what "this" is. I see that the subsections deal with Christianity alone and not "different religions". Do you have an understanding of religions other than Christianity so that you can answer this question even speculatively?

Now for the subquestions.
1. You can answer this without speculation because it is a matter of public record.
2. Again, you are asked to make conclusions on the basis of non-existent information.
3. The answer to this question relies on religious dogma. This is a physics forum.
4. Draw a parallel. What consequences did the new scientific understanding that the Earth is not the center of the Universe have on Christianity (never mind the "different" religions) back in Galileo's time? My bet is that the effect is going to be similar.
 
^ I like this answer, I don't know why any science teacher would ever ask those questions for a student's homework anyway,
 
vorcil said:
^ I like this answer, I don't know why any science teacher would ever ask those questions for a student's homework anyway,
A teacher who understood science would not ask those questions.
 
Back
Top