If you were asked for one true wish. What would be your answer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Willowz
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the concept of making a single wish, with participants sharing a variety of imaginative and serious desires. Common themes include wishes for time manipulation, such as preventing historical tragedies like the actions of Anders Behring Breivik or the destruction of the Library of Alexandria. Others express a desire for infinite wishes or to eliminate human suffering, with some suggesting a significant reduction in the global population to achieve a more sustainable world. Participants also explore the complexities of wishing for improvements in humanity, acknowledging the potential for unintended consequences. There are humorous takes on personal desires, ranging from wishing for wealth or attractiveness to more whimsical notions like becoming a Time Lord. The conversation highlights the philosophical implications of wishes, such as the burden of responsibility that comes with power and the paradox of wishing for a better world. Overall, the thread captures a blend of serious contemplation and light-hearted banter about the nature of wishes and their impact on reality.
Willowz
Messages
197
Reaction score
1
If you were asked for one true wish. What would be your answer?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
For the last few weeks, ithas been to rewind time so that Anders Behring Breivik was spontaneously aborted from his mother's womb.
 
To have no desires and wishes ever again.
 
Last edited:
micromass said:
To have no desires and wishes ever again.

Awesome answer.
 
satisfaction...
 
To get an infinite amount of wishes to be realized whenever I want, of course.
 
micromass said:
To have no desires and wishes ever again.

Easily arranged!
:gets hammer:
 
To have computers disappear from the Earth. (I'm in the software industry.)
 
To have human population level off and descend back to about 3 billion (over a few decades, of course--don't want any horrible catastrophe; just want about half of everybody to go away)
 
  • #10
Just one more wish.
 
  • #11
That nobody else had any wishes to screw up this world with.
 
  • #12
Chi Meson said:
To have human population level off and descend back to about 3 billion (over a few decades, of course--don't want any horrible catastrophe; just want about half of everybody to go away)

Have you read the book or seen the PBS production of, The Lathe of Heaven?
 
Last edited:
  • #13
Willowz said:
If you were asked for one true wish. What would be your answer?

Aside from stopping Hitler, saving humanity, changing human nature, and all of those things so clearly demonstrated to be undesireable by Fox Mulder when he had a personal Gin, one event in history that I would like to undo is the destruction of the library at Alexandria. That has always struck me as being perhaps one of the most tragic losses in all of human history.

That, or I would like to be a real Time Lord with a real TARDIS - the real Dr. Who.
 
  • #14
Chi Meson said:
To have human population level off and descend back to about 3 billion (over a few decades, of course--don't want any horrible catastrophe; just want about half of everybody to go away)

Do you have a specific half-of-all-people in mind? If not, can I add a few to the list?

Ivan Seeking said:
That, or I would like to be a real Time Lord with a real TARDIS - the real Dr. Who.

So you can reproduce asexually and never understand the value of anticipation (since they don't experience the passage of time)? I guess I wouldn't mind being a Time Lord if it meant Amy Pond followed me everywhere.

If I had one wish, I'd wish to be in middle management at an engineering company. It would be nice to never have to use my brain again. Very relaxing.
 
  • #15
I'd wish for a breakthrough in stem cell research so my sister(and those in her position) can walk again, or at least use her arms.
 
  • #16
I'd probably wish to be irresistibly attractive to women.
 
  • #17
FlexGunship said:
So you can reproduce asexually

Check

and never understand the value of anticipation (since they don't experience the passage of time)?

I haven't notice the passage of time in years. Check.


I guess I wouldn't mind being a Time Lord if it meant Amy Pond followed me everywhere.

Yeah, and how many other companions? The Doctor rarely travels alone.

If I had one wish, I'd wish to be in middle management at an engineering company. It would be nice to never have to use my brain again. Very relaxing.

Well, self-employment has its downside as well: The boss is a jerk and the employees are all idiots.
 
  • #18
A freshly ironed shirt.
 
  • #19
For infinite wishes, and for the second wish of those, the wisdom for choosing the rest of the wishes.
 
  • #20
Willowz said:
If you were asked for one true wish. What would be your answer?

Realistic, or fairy tale?

Realistic - I guess around $10M will do, should be enough for the rest of my life. I don't plan on anything extravagant, but being able to buy a better house and do some traveling would be nice.

Fairy tale? Don't even get me started... However, there is a serious problem. On many occasions people wanted to do something good, but the outcome was rather catastrophic. So while I would love to wish for something that could make the world better, I am afraid of deciding what it could be, as the results can be quite the opposite to what I want. Chi idea looks interesting, but technical realization, and possible side effects, can be even more devastating than the current flow of events is. Medical advances could be great, but the more lifes we save and the longer we live, the higher burden on the planet. Changing peoples thinking in hope it will make the world better - that was already tried and results were not necessarily encouraging (think Jesus and inquisition). So I think I will stick with my own backyard.
 
  • #21
I'm with the infinite wishes guys. The rest of you are dumbies.
 
  • #22
KingNothing said:
I'd probably wish to be irresistibly attractive to women.
That might not work out too well. Think about it.
 
  • #23
Pengwuino said:
The rest of you are [STRIKE]dumbies[/STRIKE] dummies.
Here you go Peng, fixed that for you, unless this is part of undocumented Penguin speak, in which case, I apologize. NOT...

Rhody... :smile:
 
  • #24
FlexGunship said:
Do you have a specific half-of-all-people in mind? If not, can I add a few to the list?

As you wish.





[BAM! See what I did there?]
 
  • #25
Chi Meson said:
To have human population level off and descend back to about 3 billion (over a few decades, of course--don't want any horrible catastrophe; just want about half of everybody to go away)
In Robert Sawyer's Neanderthal Parallax, they did just that. They passed a law that stopped dumb people (<50% percentile IQ) from breeding. Everyone agreed with the law because they assumed it would affect everyone else but not them. Unfortunately, you can't argue with a 50% percentile... :D


Ivan Seeking said:
Aone event in history that I would like to undo is the destruction of the library at Alexandria. That has always struck me as being perhaps one of the most tragic losses in all of human history.
Yes, the same thing has occurred to me.

We would have had our flying cars and personal jetpacks by now. :approve:
 
  • #26
If I had an unlimited number of wishes, I would have the whole universe at my feet to entertain myself. I doubt that I would continue to be concerned with events on the earth. I wouldn't care about terrorism, natural catastrophes, or second-hand smoke any more. Global warming would become infinitesimally local warming. Even if I did care about the earth, how could I change things for the better? Can I prevent murders and maintain free will, or even the illusion of free will? Can I be sure that the world would really be better off if I controlled it? I'd have to wish for the wisdom and knowledge to wish well before I wished for anything else, but then what would my next wish be? I can't know the answer to that until the first wish is fulfilled.

Would I then be responsible for guiding the outcome of every quantum event after that? Who would want such minute control? It sounds more like a burden than a benefit. What would I do about the boredom. After I've experienced the most intense pleasures the universe can afford. Experienced for the googleplexth time. After experiencing every unpleasurable thing out of boredom, after contemplating my navel for 2 and a half eternities, then what? Do it again?

I think if I were in such a situation, I would create the Earth and populate it with people that have free will. People that I can't control. In other words, delegate authority and stop with the wishes. Perhaps I'm not the first to think of it.
 
  • #27
Well, since I subscribe to Kantian morality, I would have to assume that others likewise get wishes. I also have to assume that some of those wishes would be used for nefarious purposes. Therefore, I would wish that all wishes, past, present,and future be nullified, thereby creating a paradox whcih destroys all of existence...

Wait, what was the quuestion?
 
  • #28
to stay in perfect health
 
  • #29
I wish that poverty is a man so I can kill him!To be honest, this's someone else's wish. And I don't mind to let go my fantasias wish [:biggrin:] just to make this wish come true...
 
  • #30
Nice wish drizzle! :smile: I'll remember that one...
 
  • #31
DaveC426913 said:
Yes, the same thing has occurred to me.

We would have had our flying cars and personal jetpacks by now. :approve:

I was once commenting on this to a friend; IIRC, with specific references to the medical knowledge that seems to have been lost. I had seen something about the information believed to be lost and was struck by the implications.

"I really thought you would have gotten over it by now", he replied. :smile:
 
  • #32
Ivan Seeking said:
I was once commenting on this to a friend; IIRC, with specific references to the medical knowledge that seems to have been lost. I had seen something about the information believed to be lost and was struck by the implications.

"I really thought you would have gotten over it by now", he replied. :smile:
How much history was lost when that library burned? Not just the science and mathematics of the Arabian/Persian societies and that of the early Greeks, but the historical records. I love history, and wonder how much was lost when all those scrolls went up in flames.
 
  • #33
I was going to wish for world peace, but after reading through the comments, I decided to gift my wish to Jack21222. Best of luck to your sister, with whatever is ailing her.
 
  • #34
Ms Music said:
I was going to wish for world peace, but after reading through the comments, I decided to gift my wish to Jack21222. Best of luck to your sister, with whatever is ailing her.
OK, you get my vote for Miss America!

(It's not a beauty pageant. It's a scholarship competition.)
 
  • #35
Awww, how sweet! But I would like to also gift that to someone else? My 16 year old daughter still has 2 years of high school left, but she is interning at the university in bioengineering. If anyone deserves it, that girl does! And she might even have the potential for finding the cure that Jack's sister needs. (as long as it doesn't require working with animals)
 
  • #36
Chi Meson said:
To have human population level off and descend back to about 3 billion (over a few decades, of course--don't want any horrible catastrophe; just want about half of everybody to go away)
My wish is that Chi gets his wish.
 
  • #37
Jack21222 said:
I'd wish for a breakthrough in stem cell research so my sister(and those in her position) can walk again, or at least use her arms.
I would wish that my youngest brother (and others like him) would live to see his (their) son (children) grow into adulthood. I'd gladly give 20 years of my life to him.
 
  • #38
drizzle said:
I wish that poverty is a man so I can kill him!To be honest, this's someone else's wish. And I don't mind to let go my fantasias wish [:biggrin:] just to make this wish come true...

I'd wish wealth was a man so I could kill him.
Then, we could get rid of a green-eyed monster as well, without using our wish on it. :smile:
 
  • #39
arildno said:
I'd wish wealth was a man so I could kill him.
Then, we could get rid of a green-eyed monster as well, without using our wish on it. :smile:

I know my wish sounds unreal, but think about it.. If you get rid of poorness, somehow wealthy people might die, by heart attack or something... :biggrin:
 
  • #40
drizzle said:
I know it sounds unreal, but think about it.. If you get rid of poorness, somehow wealthy people might die, by heart attack or something... :biggrin:

I don't follow that thought at all.
 
  • #41
I'd wish I was a little bit taller, wish I was a baller.

Oops, that's two.
 
  • #42
Mororvia said:
I'd wish I was a little bit taller, wish I was a baller.
a baller?

I do not sink zat means what you sink it means.
 
  • #43
I wish I could figure out how to change my attitude, how to straighten up.
 
  • #44
Newai said:
I wish I could figure out how to change my attitude, how to straighten up.
Put the pipe down.
 
  • #45
I haven't mentioned my wish. I wish that I knew what I should wish for.
 
  • #46
Willowz said:
Put the pipe down.

I don't smoke, do drugs, or drink. Anything else?
 
  • #47
Newai said:
I don't smoke, do drugs, or drink. Anything else?

Yeah. Lose the 'tude.

:smile:
 
  • #48
You misinterpreted my tone.
 
  • #49
Newai said:
I don't smoke, do drugs, or drink. Anything else?
Then, you sound straightened up to me.
 
  • #50
Ivan Seeking said:
Have you read the book or seen the PBS production of, The Lathe of Heaven?

To meet Ursula...

I went to an art show, with the book in hand, as I was a great fan of the production.
http://www.opb.org/programs/artbeat/segments/view/570" said Ursula would be there.

I missed her by 10 minutes. :cry:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
21
Views
2K
Back
Top