Is (1-Exp[-i x])^2 equal to Sin^2(x) in particle physics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter y35dp
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Exponential Trig
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the mathematical expression (1-Exp[-i x])^2 and its relation to Sin^2(x) in particle physics. Participants clarify that these two expressions are not equal, providing an example with x=π/2 to illustrate the discrepancy. The initial confusion stems from interpreting the question and the algebra involved, leading to a consensus that the issue lies not in the math but potentially in the physics context. The conversation highlights the importance of clear problem presentation in physics discussions. Ultimately, the expressions are confirmed to be distinct.
y35dp
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
start point (1-Exp[-i x])^2, (i^2 = -1)

finish point Sin^2(x)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
umm... I don't quite understand what your question is or what to make of what you wrote.
 
I would interpret this as "given f(x)= (1- e^{-ix})^2 show that f(x)= sin^2(x).

Except for the slight problem that they are NOT equal! For example, when x= \pi/2, 1- e^{-i\pi/2}= 1+ i while sin^2(\pi/2)= 1.

y35dp, can you please tell us what the problem really is?
 
That was my initial thought, that it was asking to show (1-e^{-ix})^2\equiv sin^2x but it isn't true so I was at a complete loss.

Whatever happened to the starter thread layout with the problem, equations and attempt titles?
 
ok this confirms my thoughts that the two aren't equal this is a particle physics problem but i though the issue was my algebra but the issue must be with my physics!
 
Back
Top