Is Fire Considered Matter and What State Does It Belong To?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dremmer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Fire Matter
AI Thread Summary
Fire is primarily considered a chemical process rather than matter itself, as it does not behave like typical matter. While fire involves the combustion of materials, it produces gases and heat, making it difficult to categorize within the traditional states of matter. The discussion highlights that many commonly held beliefs about fire and science are often misconceptions. Some participants argue that fire can be viewed as matter due to its physical manifestations like flames and smoke, while others emphasize the importance of understanding the underlying processes. Ultimately, the consensus leans towards defining fire as a process rather than a distinct state of matter.
Dremmer
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
And if so, what state of matter is it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
A coal fire is a mixture of solids and gases - with possibly some 'liquid' if there happens to be any melting non-specific 'gunge' in the hot coal. The word "fire" refers more to a process than a substance.
Science is really above these things, though. There is little point in trying to 'categorise' everything in the world. The 'three states of matter' (plus Plasma) are very coarse categories and there are many many common substances that fall into more than one.
We have the same problem if we want to categorise life forms, electromagnetic waves, signals and many others. Life's too short and it doesn't help at all with our understanding - quite the reverse, in fact, I think.
 
Hydrogen fire is plasma.
 
and gas!
 
Is fire matter?
No, it is not.
 
It doesn't behave like typical matter, which makes some people believe that it is not actually matter.
 
Dremmer said:
It doesn't behave like typical matter, which makes some people believe that it is not actually matter.

Huh? Why are you asking the question if you're not going to listen to the answers?

Fire is not matter; it's a chemical process. Rusting is not matter either, nor is freezing.
There's nothing in a fire that was not there before, and nothing left after a fire that wasn't there before that.
 
First of all, define precisely what you mean by "fire". Just flame? Process? Everything that we see when looking at fire, that is something that burns, flames and smoke?
 
I think that when most people think of fire, they think of the flames.
 
  • #10
"Most people" don't have very well informed opinions, in general, about Science so a lot of popularly held views of Science are faulty.
e.g. "Current takes the easiest route"
"Nature abhors a vacuum"
"Warm air can hold a lot of water"
etc.
etc.
Isn't the point of this Forum to get things as right as possible?
 
  • #11
From my understanding, matter is anything that takes up space and has mass. So rather than asking "if fire is matter," you should probably ask yourself, "what parts of fire make up matter?"*

* Is Fire Matter?. (n.d.). NEWTON/ANL Home Page. Retrieved November 25, 2010, from http://www.Newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci
 
  • #12
Dead link (at least for me), I'm afraid.
 
  • #13
sophiecentaur said:
Dead link (at least for me), I'm afraid.

I'm sorry, it was working for me not too long ago, but it was just part of my citation.
 
  • #14
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #15
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Back
Top