Is Geography a science? It is comprised of theories, Laws and rules

AI Thread Summary
Geography is debated as a science due to its incorporation of theories, laws, hypotheses, and mathematical equations, along with elements of physics, chemistry, and biology. It can be classified as a science if defined by the ability to test theories through experimentation. Historical examples, such as the study of the Appalachian Mountains and their impact on human evolution, support this classification. The use of scientific jargon also aligns geography with scientific disciplines. However, some argue against its scientific status, citing the age of successful geography competitors, suggesting that the term "physical geography" could solidify its scientific classification. Overall, geography encompasses a broad area of study with much still to explore.
log(3.14)
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Is Geography a science? It is comprised of theories, Laws (well Rules realy), hypothesis, some Math equations, aspects of Physics Chemistry and Biology. Also there is still much to be learned from it.
 
Earth sciences news on Phys.org


I would judge it to be a science covering a very broad area.
 


log(3.14) said:
Is Geography a science?
If you define a science as a discipline in which theories can be tested by experiment, then geography is indeed a science.

For instance, about 450 million years ago, scientists erected the Appalachian mountains to see if people to the west of it would evolve differently from those on the east. The existence of California proved them correct. The Rockies were not erected as an experiment, but by well intentioned easterners who felt that the harder it was for Californians to communicate with the real world, the better.

Another definition of a science is that it uses a lot of scientific jargon. Here, for example, is the wiki page on geography. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geography" . Works for me.

On the other hand, most scientists do their best work in their 20's, but most winners of the National Geography Bee are in their teens, so maybe it's not a science after all. But even if it weren't a science, you could make it one by adding the word physical in front of it as in physical astrology or physical chemistry. So call it physical geography and be done with it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:


jimmysnyder said:
Another definition of a science is that it uses a lot of scientific jargon. Here, for example, is the wiki page on geography. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geography" . Works for me.

I didn't get that link working, so here is what you might have meant.

http://uncyclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/Geography"
 
Last edited by a moderator:


jimmysnyder said:
For instance, about 450 million years ago, scientists erected the Appalachian mountains to see if people to the west of it would evolve differently from those on the east. The existence of California proved them correct. The Rockies were not erected as an experiment, but by well intentioned easterners who felt that the harder it was for Californians to communicate with the real world, the better.

.

Love this!
 


earth science?
 
Hello, I’m currently writing a series of essays on Pangaea, continental drift, and Earth’s geological cycles. While working on my research, I’ve come across some inconsistencies in the existing theories — for example, why the main pressure seems to have been concentrated in the northern polar regions. So I’m curious: is there any data or evidence suggesting that an external cosmic body (an asteroid, comet, or another massive object) could have influenced Earth’s geology in the distant...
On August 10, 2025, there was a massive landslide on the eastern side of Tracy Arm fjord. Although some sources mention 1000 ft tsunami, that height represents the run-up on the sides of the fjord. Technically it was a seiche. Early View of Tracy Arm Landslide Features Tsunami-causing slide was largest in decade, earthquake center finds https://www.gi.alaska.edu/news/tsunami-causing-slide-was-largest-decade-earthquake-center-finds...

Similar threads

Back
Top