Is there a circuit or device that does this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter iScience
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circuit Device
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the feasibility of a circuit or device that can take an input signal, amplify it, and output it at a higher voltage while maintaining a zero-degree phase shift. Participants explore the implications of this requirement in the context of electrical engineering, particularly regarding power transmission and signal processing.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster (OP) seeks a circuit that outputs a signal that is 0° out of phase with the input and at a higher voltage.
  • Some participants question the clarity of the OP's request, particularly the meaning of "pushed back outward" and the implications of phase shifting.
  • One participant suggests that achieving zero degrees phase shift is dependent on the measurement point, especially in high-frequency applications.
  • Another participant notes that while power has a direction of travel on a transmission line, signals can propagate in both directions independently.
  • Concerns are raised about the OP's unspecified input and output impedances and the implications for circuit design.
  • A suggestion is made that a directional coupler may be necessary to manage power flow and prevent oscillation in the proposed circuit.
  • Participants discuss the concept of grid tie inverters, which push power back into the grid and operate in phase with the grid voltage.
  • The OP clarifies their goal of syncing an external power supply with wall power to potentially reverse a watt meter's reading.
  • Some participants express skepticism about the feasibility of the OP's idea, particularly regarding the control of output voltage in a low impedance network.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and disagreement regarding the feasibility of the OP's request. While some acknowledge the theoretical possibility of achieving the desired outcome, others highlight significant practical challenges and uncertainties that remain unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the OP's requirements involve assumptions about impedance and power flow that are not fully defined. There is also mention of potential limitations related to different types of energy meters and their ability to accurately measure power in the proposed scenario.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to individuals exploring circuit design, power electronics, and those involved in renewable energy systems or grid integration technologies.

iScience
Messages
466
Reaction score
5
im looking for a circuit with this ability.


so you have a signal input going into this circuit. and this circuit has an external power supply. this circuit outputs its signal where the input comes in. the thing is, i want the output signal to be 0° out of phase with the input and higher voltage than the input such that the input signal is being pushed back outward. is there by any chance.. any circuit that can do this?

thanks
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Makes no sense. Exactly how much do you understand about electricity?
 
what do you mean by "the circuit outputs its signal where the input comes in"?
what do you mean by "the input signal being pushed back outward"? like in phase shifted? i that's the case, shifted as compared to the output? then you can't have 0 degrees out of phase.
 
This does make sense, but only at and above radio frequencies.
It is easy with microwaves because you can use circulators and directional couplers.
The specification of zero degrees phase shift depends on where you measure it because the output signal is traveling in the opposite direction to the input signal on the transmission line.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Baluncore:
I have never looked into it to be sure on definitions and etc., but I think typically only POWER has a direction of travel on a transmission line. We don't really consider signals in this manner do we? I would add that what you say about radio frequencies certainly applies, but the physics and theory is the same with lower frequencies, just typically impractical due to the wavelengths and transmission line lengths.
-
We need the OP to give us some more info.
 
Averagesupernova said:
...but I think typically only POWER has a direction of travel on a transmission line. We don't really consider signals in this manner do we?”...
Not only do I think about signals in those terms, but I use it every day.

A linear transmission line propagates signals in both directions quite independently. Each signal has a voltage to current ratio equal to the characteristic impedance of the line. Telecommunications networking has no problem with that. There is a “hybrid” coupler in a line telephone that works quite OK at audio frequencies, but careful adjustment is required to prevent echo. It is more obviously possible when you consider that a submarine optic fibre carries signals in both directions on the one fibre. You can also take a photo, of yourself taking the photo, in a mirror.

We do need more information from the OP because “zero phase shift at one common terminal” suggests in the first analysis that positive feedback will be a problem. But that is certainly not the case.

The OP required the amplified signal to be in phase. It did not specify that the carrier of that signal must also be in phase. For example an FM radio receiver that uses it's speaker lead as the antenna.

Only the OP can refine or expand the question to identify the situation.
 
Baluncore, you have somewhat missed my point. Telephone circuits do indeed have 'signals' flowing in both directions. BUT, I believe they always are working with a specific impedance. So there IS power flowing. The ends of the lines are terminated. The OP implies that he wants to throw a voltage at a port with unspecified input impedance from a source with an unspecified output impedance.
-
What this part means I have no idea:
...such that the input signal is being pushed back outward.

The OP's post alone makes NO SENSE, and won't work. To actually make something like this work there needs to be a directional coupler between the generator and said device and a port on this directional coupler that is terminated to absorb the power being reflected back towards the source but not from the source. The magic device he is wondering about will need to have some kind of hybrid circuitry inside to help prevent oscillation.
-
If we want to reflect a signal all we need is an unterminated transmission line of the correct length and virtually 100% of the power will be reflected back towards the source. Is the input signal being 'pushed back outward' as the OP says? You tell me. The whole thing is sort of a mind-bender.
 
Since the characteristic impedance of the line is the same in both directions, the OP requirement that the output signal be “higher voltage than the input” requires some form of power amplification.

If power gain was not required the answer to the OP question could be as you suggest, “A mirror”.

We must await refinement of the OP.
 
I just reread my 3rd post in this thread.
-
So there IS power flowing.

The above comment I made looks somewhat silly. I could have chosen words more carefully.
 
  • #10
Basically that is a Grid Tie Inverter - power source is solar array, the circuit does not operate unless there is a tie to the grid ( V AC present) - and the inverter "pushes" power out, ideally at unity PF.

Somewhat of a wise-a comment - but technically does the task as I read the OP.
 
  • #11
Well identified Windadct.
Those inverters push out current that is in phase with the voltage on the low impedance supply grid.

One problem with too many grid connected solar power inverters on anyone part of the grid is that if the main supply is lost or disconnected, the inverters can slave off each other and continue to run. Now that is an interesting case of positive community feedback. It becomes even more interesting when trying to reconnect the main supply since there is no immediate control over the phase of either and so the operator must wait for the right instant to throw the switch. I know one dedicated operator who has had nightmares about it.
 
  • #12
hey all, thanks for all the responses, i apologize for the long delay on this thread.

basically i am looking to see if something like this is possible. where i have a power supply, and this power supply is in phase with the wall power. the voltage of this power supply will always be greater than the wall power.

first thing's first; will it be possible to put power back into the grid, ie turn my watt meter backwards this way?

the hypothetical device i was looking for in the beginning of this thread was to get the phases in sync. as baluncore suggested, this device would be like a mirror, except power gain is indeed required.

i have another general plan of getting the two in phase, but... it's a LOT less reliable.

will the idea work? (external power supply in sync with wall signal, whose voltage is also always greater than wall power, plug external power supply into wall and make watt meter turn backwards)
 
  • #13
oh, and to:

Averagesupernova said:
Makes no sense. Exactly how much do you understand about electricity?

i am not an EE major. i do not even have a degree in anything. I'm just a college kid at a mediocre school. go easy :)
 
  • #14
Now that you have identified the application it is possible to refine the way you are looking at the problem. You will have no control of the output voltage because you cannot fight the very low impedance network.

So follow the voltage on the network and then inject a current into the network that is in phase with the voltage. If the injected current comes from an alternative energy source then it should turn your meter backwards. Your system must shut down if there is low voltage on the network, then wait before restarting.

Now a couple of problems to look out for. If your energy meter is a rotating disk it should run backwards but there are a few that have a one way contact or ratchet installed.

If your meter is a new digital meter then it will probably measure the average voltage over a cycle and the average current over a cycle. It will then multiply those to get power and accumulate the reading. Unfortunately most metres do not consider the direction of the current so it will cost you to generate power. This way you will also pay for any circulating reactive currents as well as real power.

Gone are the days when we purchased energy here, we now purchase the change in meter reading.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
55
Views
8K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
944
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
3K