Is there something wrong with this wave concept?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jsun.12
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Concept Wave
AI Thread Summary
As the wavelength of a wave in a uniform medium increases, its speed remains constant, contradicting the initial assumption that it would increase. The frequency decreases because wavelength and frequency are inversely proportional, meaning that as one increases, the other must decrease. The confusion arises from mixing concepts of wave behavior in different media, particularly regarding refraction. In a uniform medium, the wave speed is determined by the medium itself, not the wavelength or frequency. Understanding these relationships clarifies the behavior of waves in consistent conditions.
jsun.12
Messages
6
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



1. As the wavelength of a wave in a uniform medium increases, its speed will _____.

a. decrease


b. increase


c. remain the same


2. As the wavelength of a wave in a uniform medium increases, its frequency will _____.

a. decrease


b. increase


c. remain the same


Homework Equations



v = λf
f = 1/T
v = λ/T


The Attempt at a Solution



1. I answered B, increase, but it says the answer is C.

2. I answered C, because I know frequency does not change; only the wavelength changes. But then, the answer says it decreases because the wavelength and frequency are inversely proportional.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Problem 2 is kind of the answer to problem 1. Since the velocity is constant*frequency*wavelength, if the wavelength goes down the frequency goes up to compensate. The wave still travels with respect to the speed of light in the medium.
 
Mindscrape said:
Problem 2 is kind of the answer to problem 1. Since the velocity is constant*frequency*wavelength, if the wavelength goes down the frequency goes up to compensate. The wave still travels with respect to the speed of light in the medium.
But I am confused at the moment because what I read is that frequency of a wave does not change, only the wavelength :|.
 
Frequency is number of waves per second, so if the length of a wave gets smaller then more waves will fit in one second time.
 
The wave speed is determined by the medium. So, if the medium doesn't change, the speed can't either.

You are confused because you are thinking of *refraction* in which the wave goes from one medium to another different medium. In this case, the wave speed can change at the interface (because the medium has changed), but the frequency cannot change at the interface, becuase if it did, you would be magically gaining or losing wavefronts.
 
cepheid said:
The wave speed is determined by the medium. So, if the medium doesn't change, the speed can't either.

You are confused because you are thinking of *refraction* in which the wave goes from one medium to another different medium. In this case, the wave speed can change at the interface (because the medium has changed), but the frequency cannot change at the interface, becuase if it did, you would be magically gaining or losing wavefronts.
Oh I get it now lol. The answer I was looking for :P. thx
 
Mindscrape said:
Frequency is number of waves per second, so if the length of a wave gets smaller then more waves will fit in one second time.
Yeah makes sense. thanks!
 
Back
Top