Justify the number of significant figures for x

  1. hi we did an experiment at school and in my homework i am asked to justify the number of significant figures for x.
    what do they mean with justify here? i dont understand the question.
    my x value has 3 s.f.

    thanks in advance
     
  2. jcsd
  3. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    If your x value is a product or sum of different numbers, then it can only contain a certain amount of significant figures, and you can't justify any more than that. So if in your experiment you ended up multiplying 2.13 by 4.17, your calculator gives an answer of 8.8821, but per the sig fig rule, you can only justify the answer to 3 sig figs, so the answer is 8.88. Is that what you mean for your 'x' value?
     
  4. Re: justify

    thanks but that's not actually what i mean with my x- value.
    the x value was an unknown in an equation and i had to work out this x value.
    it represents the mass of a mug.
    then after i have made the x value the subject of my equation they ask me that question which i have written in my first post.
    what do i have to do?
    and what does justify mean in this context?
     
  5. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    Yes, I think that is the example of what i said.. Please show the equation that you used to solve for x. You said that x had 3 sig figures...does it?? You can only justify as many sig figures in your answer as sig fig rules allow. If y = zx, then x =y/z, and if y is 2.42 and z is 1.23, then the answer for x is 1.97, not 1.96747967..., because there are only 3 sig figures in the values of y and z, and therefore x can only have 3 sig figures, not a whole bunch of them. Am I understanding your question correctly?
     
  6. Re: justify

    Oh I think I understand .
    But say the equation was y=0.6zx
    so x= y/0.6z
    x and y are given to 3 s.f
    But the 0.6 is just given to 1 s.f.
    will x still have 3 s.f. or does the 0.6 affect the number of s.f of x?
     
  7. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    When multiplying or dividing, the answer is only as good as the number of the least significant digits of any numbers in the problem. Since 0.6 has only 1 sig fig, then the answer can only have one sig figure. Unless the '0.6' is an exact known number. As for example how much is 9 times 9....you can't say 80 , which is correct to one sig fig, or you'll flunk 2nd grade. But if you weighed something by experiment and it weighed 9 N, then 9 of those somethings would weigh 80 N. If you weighed it at 9.0 N, then 9 of them weigh 81 N. Sig fig rules get confusing.
     
  8. Re: justify

    but in my equation the 0.6 is an exact known number and all the other numbers are measured to3 sf
    how about now?
     
  9. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    Then the answer should have 3 significant figures.
     
  10. Re: justify

    sorry to ask again but is it right what I have understood so far.
    When I 've got y=0.6zx then you get x=y/0.6z
    At school we measured y and z to 3 sf. So does it mean that 0.6 is kind of a constant value and it doesn't affect the value of x which I am trying to work out? Because I didn't work out 0.6. This was the only number given in the equation but the other numbers which I have plugged into the equation are measured values.
    So does x also have 3 sf then?
    Can you explain that again please. I am slightly confused.
    Thanks in advance
     
  11. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    Yes, if the 0.6 is an exact known number, it theoretically has an infinite number of significant digits, that is, you can call it 0.6000000000000000000. In multiplying or dividing, the result can have only as many significant figures as the least number of significant values in any number used in the problem, so that in your case, x must have 3 significant figures. As an example, if y = 1.23 (3 sig figures) and z = 0.629 (3 significant figures), then x = y/0.6z = 1.23/0.6(.629) = 3.26 (3 sig figs). The real difficulty is in determing the number of sig figs in a number, for sample, if experimentaly, one value is 0.002 (1 significant figure) and the other value is 0.111 (3 sig figures), and you wanted to multiply them together, then the answer is (.002)(.111) = 0.0002 (which has 1 sig fig), not 0.000222, which would have 3 sig figs, which is too many to use. Confusing.
     
  12. Re: justify

    When you say 0.6 is an exact known number is that the same as saying it's a constant?

    And are you trying to tell me that a constant doesn't affect the final result ?
    Am i right?

    If I would have this example:

    (0.333)(0.550)/0.2

    where 0.2 is the value already given in the equation( so a constant?) and 0.333 and 0.550 are measured values. Is the answer going to have 3 sf????
     
  13. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    Yes, correct, as long as the constant that is given to you is an exact known number. Sometimes the number 'pi' is given to you as 3.14 even though its value is 3.14159... .
    Thus, if you were asked to calculate the circumference of a circle (C = pi(diameter)) having a measured diameter of 123.4 units (4 sig figures), and the problem said use pi= 3.14 (which has 3 sig figs), then the answer is C = 387 units (3 sig figs). But if it said calculate the circumference of the circle but did not put an approximation on pi, then C = 387.7 units.
     
  14. Re: justify

    Ok I understand what you are saying but can you also answer the last bit of my question with the calculation please :)

    And does 0.550 actually have 2 or 3 sf?
    And how do I know that 0.2 is an exact known number- this value is just given in the equation ?
    thanks
     
  15. PhanthomJay

    PhanthomJay 6,276
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Re: justify

    yes, the ans has 3 sig figs
    it has 3. The number 0.005 has 1. Google on 'significant figures'.
    You don't know for sure unless you can identify it as such or were given it as such. For example, the area of a right triangle is 0.5(b)(h). The 0.5 is exact in this example.
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share a link to this question via email, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?
Similar discussions for: Justify the number of significant figures for x
Loading...