Light from Big Bang: 14 Billion Years Old and Counting

  • Thread starter Thread starter 4everphysics
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the nature of light from the Big Bang, specifically the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) and its journey to Earth. It is clarified that while the light we observe is approximately 14 billion years old, the source of this light is now about 46 billion light years away due to the universe's expansion. The time it takes for new light from this source to reach us will continue to increase without bound, but it will never actually reach infinity, remaining a finite duration. As the universe expands, the wavelengths of this light will redshift, eventually making it undetectable as it exceeds the cosmic background radiation. The conversation emphasizes the complexities of cosmological expansion and the implications for the visibility of distant objects over time.
4everphysics
Messages
19
Reaction score
0
Question:
Please correct me if I am wrong:
the oldest light that we just begin to receive is around 14 billion light years old.

This light originated from a lightsource that was about
30 million light years away (380,000 years after big bang.)

So although the lightsource was 30 million light years away, the light took about 14 billion light years to reach us, because of the expansion of the universe.

At the present, the lightsource is physically located about 46 billion light years away from us. (although its light has traveled 14 billion years only).

However, by the same reasoning, the light that is just leaving the light source will take more than 46 billion light years to reach us.

Therefore, the new light from the identical light source takes significantly longer time to reach us. As more and more new light is formed, then, the time it takes for the new light to reach us will evermore increase, until it increases to infinity.

Therefore, the object will some day no longer be visible.

Is my reasoning correct? Also, if this is correct, does that mean
the object that we barely begin to see
(the first light from big bang reaching us as a cosmic microwave background),
will appear as a cosmic microwave background
and then disappear completely in the later future?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
It will continue to redshift until its wavelength exceeds the cosmic background radiation. It will then be undetectable.
 
Also, I think the time to reach us does approach infinity, but I think it will remain finite for any finite amount of time. So it would take an infinite amount of time for it to no longer be visible.
 
Chronos said:
It will continue to redshift until its wavelength exceeds the cosmic background radiation. It will then be undetectable.

Would it ever exceed the wavelength of the CMB?
 
4everphysics said:
the time it takes for the new light to reach us will evermore increase, until it increases to infinity.

Therefore, the object will some day no longer be visible.

Is my reasoning correct?

No. Your reasoning is too loose. It is more correct to say that the time it takes for the light to reach us increases without bound. But it will never reach infinity. It will always be a finite number.
 
4ever...that explanation seems really good...congrats!
Here is another I keep in my notes [from these forums] almost like yours, but you'll see it starts a little earlier, uses 41mly instead of your 30mly at age 380,000 yrs, and shows how the scalefactor works:

When it is said that in the beginning the universe was the size of a very dense pea what is being referred to is the then visible part of the universe, the small part we can see out to the origin of the CMB. The actual universe at that time extended past that radius perhaps even infinitely...
We only get the CMBR light from some particular batch of early matter once and it passes by. Tomorrow we will get light from matter that is farther away than that batch of light we got yesterday because the universe continues to expand. The source of the CMBR [the surface of last scattering] is now about 45b light yrs away, [it slowly increases as the universe gets older] but the CMBR light we get was emitted 13.7 billion years ago...since then, while the light has been traveling towards us the universe has expanded by a factor of 1090, the cosmic expansion and redshift z =1091, so the distance then must have been 45 bly divided by 1091 or 41mlyr.

Also if you are interested, see the illustrations by Lineweaver and Davis here, figure 1:

http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0310808

They take some careful reading, some thought and study, but if you can figure them out, you'll have a throrough understanding of cosmological expansion and measures...and then you can explain them to me!
 
Thank you so much for all your help everyone! and Naty1, thank you for such a strong enthusiasm. I will sure read that article and ask you more if you do not mind!
Sincerely
 
Back
Top