Relativity Looking for a good intermediate book on SR

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scrumhalf
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Book Sr
AI Thread Summary
A 10th grader seeking a more advanced relativity book is currently reading "An Illustrated Guide to Relativity" by Takeuchi and "General Relativity A to B" by Geroch. With a solid background in AP Calculus BC, the student is ready for a rigorous mathematical treatment of relativity. Recommendations include Shankar's "Fundamentals of Physics I," which offers a comprehensive approach, and Tom Moore's "Six Ideas That Shaped Physics: Unit R," which is more mathematically appropriate. Ed Taylor and J.A. Wheeler's "Spacetime Physics" is also suggested, with a preference for the 1966 edition due to its inclusion of worked problems and references to rapidity, which were omitted in later editions. The discussion highlights the importance of choosing texts that balance theoretical depth with mathematical rigor for advanced high school students.
Scrumhalf
Gold Member
Messages
98
Reaction score
61
My 10th grader is looking for a relativity book that is bit more advanced than the ones he has been reading, which are An Illustrated Guide to Relativity by Takeuichi, and General Relativity A to B by Gerach.

He has completed AP Calculus BC, so he has a good handle on single variable calculus and is ready for a book that has a more rigorous mathematical treatment of the topics.

Any recommendations? Thanks in advance!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Shankar's Fundamentals of Physics I has a good treatment at that level, and covers more besides.
 
That's General Relativity A to B by Geroch. (Although it looks simple, it's remarkably deep theoretically...addressing issues found nowhere else [intro or advanced]. I realized this when I sat for his graduate course in GR and recalled what I read in A-to-B.
Geroch's graduate-level lecture notes have been published
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0987987178/?tag=pfamazon01-20
but that's too much of a step from just A-to-B.)

For something more appropriate (math wise),
Tom Moore's Six Ideas That Shaped Physics: Unit R
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0072397144/?tag=pfamazon01-20
however, there is a 3rd edition out now (http://www.physics.pomona.edu/sixideas/
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0077600959/?tag=pfamazon01-20 )

Ed Taylor and J.A. Wheeler's Spacetime Physics
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0716723271/?tag=pfamazon01-20
however, I much prefer the 1966 maroon edition with the worked problems ( see http://www.eftaylor.com/special.html )
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes QuantumQuest
I recently bought both the 1966 edition of Spacetime Physics and the latest version and there is about 50% more content in the latest one.
Just out of curiosity, what is it that makes you strongly prefer the older one?
 
While the 2nd edition has some good answers to "student questions", the 1st-edition-with-worked-solutions is valuable. There are 1st editions that do not have the worked-solutions section. The 2nd edition doesn't have the worked-solutions.

In addition, the 1st edition had references to rapidity. Ed told me that they dropped it in the 2nd edition because some folks reported that they didn't use it. A group of us strongly suggested he include it in a future edition.
 
Thank you very much for the recommendations! Sorry for the late reply as I was traveling and didn't have ready access to this forum.
 
The book is fascinating. If your education includes a typical math degree curriculum, with Lebesgue integration, functional analysis, etc, it teaches QFT with only a passing acquaintance of ordinary QM you would get at HS. However, I would read Lenny Susskind's book on QM first. Purchased a copy straight away, but it will not arrive until the end of December; however, Scribd has a PDF I am now studying. The first part introduces distribution theory (and other related concepts), which...
I've gone through the Standard turbulence textbooks such as Pope's Turbulent Flows and Wilcox' Turbulent modelling for CFD which mostly Covers RANS and the closure models. I want to jump more into DNS but most of the work i've been able to come across is too "practical" and not much explanation of the theory behind it. I wonder if there is a book that takes a theoretical approach to Turbulence starting from the full Navier Stokes Equations and developing from there, instead of jumping from...
Back
Top