Classical Mechanics Book for self learner?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on selecting a suitable classical mechanics textbook for self-study alongside advanced calculus courses. The original poster expresses a desire for a higher-level text than the introductory materials they currently have, considering options like Kleppner/Kolenkow (K&K), French, Morin, and others. Recommendations include French's "Newtonian Mechanics" for its accessibility and completeness, while K&K is noted for its challenge and lack of a solutions manual. Other advanced texts such as Landau/Lifshitz and V. Arnold's "Mathematical Methods in Classical Mechanics" are suggested for those seeking a rigorous challenge, though they require a solid foundation in physics and mathematics. The importance of having a mentor or supervisor for guidance in tackling these complex texts is emphasized, along with the suggestion to study calculus of variations and linear algebra to support understanding in advanced mechanics and other physics areas.
CrunchBerries
Messages
58
Reaction score
8
I am planning on doing physics as I go through calc2/3/ODE/PDE.

I bought University Physics and the Resnick/Jearl Physics book, and frankly I want something a bit higher level.. more like Kleppner/Kolenkow.

I was thinking about getting the K&K book, but some people are suggesting Morin, French, Spivak, Goldstein, Taylor, Feynman etc..

I guess I'm asking which classical mechanics book would be a better self learner book, with available solutions somewhere.

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
My personal choices are French' Newtonian Mechanics and K&K. I don't believe a solutions manual for K&K exists, and it is a challenging book. Self-study may be difficult but it is well worth going through.
 
  • Like
Likes CrunchBerries
Thank you, ordered the AP French Mech book. It does have all the answers. Ill go through it slowly over time, if there are any issues with my attempts i might refer to another book to compliment. Maybe a more modern treatment like Morin.. looks like they are good complementary texts.
 
If you want a real challenge, I recommend the first volume of Landau/Lifshitz's trilogy in theoretical physics or V. Arnold's "Mathematical Methods in Classical Mechanics". They can be served as an excellent introduction to mechanics if you are willing to learn necessary concepts in mathematics as you go along the book.
 
  • Like
Likes CrunchBerries
Thanks, looks like a good book in preparation to what I want to do, cheers!
 
bacte2013 said:
If you want a real challenge, I recommend the first volume of Landau/Lifshitz's trilogy in theoretical physics or V. Arnold's "Mathematical Methods in Classical Mechanics". They can be served as an excellent introduction to mechanics if you are willing to learn necessary concepts in mathematics as you go along the book.

This is probably going to be something I do after I complete French's mechanics. Looks like Landun/Lifshitz really turn the dial up, I think I'll need a solid basic physics/math background before I can tackle that. I think I will end up getting this and Purcell's E&M book when I finish my ODE/PDE courses.
 
CrunchBerries said:
This is probably going to be something I do after I complete French's mechanics. Looks like Landun/Lifshitz really turn the dial up, I think I'll need a solid basic physics/math background before I can tackle that. I think I will end up getting this and Purcell's E&M book when I finish my ODE/PDE courses.

By any chance, do you have a teacher, professor, or even graduate student who can invest his/her time to supervise your reading? L/L and Arnold were my first exposure to physics (except for AP Physics), and I did not have much trouble understanding the mechanics. Of course, I read the book under a supervision of a faculty member who can provide a high-quality explanation and derive equations. Although it is my personal opinion, L/L made basic concepts not precisely clear, which made me to actually come up with my own definitions and adjusted them with a supervisor's help. If you have someone very experience in physics that might be interested in doing a reading course with you, I highly recommend re-thinking about postponing L/L.

Also, you might also want to study calculus of variations and linear algebra (including topics such as tensor algebra) now (you seem to have sufficient prerequisites). They are heavily used not only in advanced mechanics but also other branches of physics (at least I know that they are used heavily in QM and relativity). I assume you already completed Calculus I-III?
 

Similar threads

Replies
23
Views
5K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
5K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
5K
Back
Top