Mgnetic field

is it true that the earths magnetic field is changing so that magnetic north will be directional south and vice versa.
and if so how is it doing it
 
1,068
7
Scientists have long known that the magnetic pole moves. James Ross located the pole for the first time in 1831 after an exhausting arctic journey during which his ship got stuck in the ice for four years. No one returned until the next century. In 1904, Roald Amundsen found the pole again and discovered that it had moved--at least 50 km since the days of Ross.
http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2003/29dec_magneticfield.htm [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes, the poles do reverse every so often. I'm not sure how they do it though. I just know that we can see it in rocks. Rock keeps a long history of where the poles were at such and such time. They do this like a compase with a needle. The poles attract certain elements in the rock, which make them piont at where the pole is attracting them from. Theres probably more to this but just to give you the basic idea I posted.
 

zoobyshoe

Bipedal Hairy Critter
5,817
1,268
Mr. dude said:
The poles attract certain elements in the rock, which make them piont at where the pole is attracting them from. Theres probably more to this but just to give you the basic idea I posted.
The "more to it" is that to be susceptible to picking up the same orientation as the then current magnetic poles, the rocks have to be hot enough for their magnetic domains to realign with the earth's field. Because of this, it should be clear why most of this rock with ancient compass orientations frozen into it is found around volcanos.

However, they have also discovered a hot fire can do the same thing to underlying soil. Ancient firepits have been roughly dated by finding the magnetic orientation of the iron in the soil beneath the charcoal, and comparing it to the dates they ascribed to the earth's poles being similarly oriented.

The poles are never fixed. They are constantly wandering around. They don't know why for sure because no one knows the cause of the Earth's magnetic field for sure. Many, many teams of people are working on trying to solve this mystery.
 
So would there also be compass orientations on the bottom of the ocean from sea floor spreading?
 

SOS2008

Gold Member
0
0
Some believe the magnetic force field is expected to reverse in the near future. The reasoning being that the force field fades before reversal, and measurements indicate a 10% decrease in strength over the last 100 years or so. Currently the poles are moving about 10 miles each year. The decrease results in loss of atmosphere and increased exposure to solar flares. Aside from havoc it causes to instruments and even animals that also rely on directional magnetism, theoretically the entire atmosphere could be lost if the field is too weak for too long.
 
4,356
47
even animals that also rely on directional magnetism,
But do they really? We know now that the Earth Magnetic field had collapsed about every 100,000 year in the current Brunhes Chron, the last ~800,000 years ago. If the migrating birds and other animals really relied on a biologic compass, how did they cope with that? It doesn't appear to have led to multiple extinctions.

Don't worry about the effects on human orientation. We'll all have GPS in our camera/MPEG payer/cell phone in less than a decade
 

zoobyshoe

Bipedal Hairy Critter
5,817
1,268
SOS2008 said:
The decrease results in loss of atmosphere...
I hadn't heard this. You wouldn't happen to have a link to a discussion/explanation of this would you?
 

SOS2008

Gold Member
0
0
zoobyshoe said:
I hadn't heard this. You wouldn't happen to have a link to a discussion/explanation of this would you?
A quick Internet search with "Magnetic Field and Atmosphere" yielded several sites on the topic. There are different variables, the sun's magnetic field or "Interplanetary Magnetic Field" or "IMF," the solar winds, the density of a planet's atmosphere, etc.

Earth has a magnetic field, too. It forms a bubble around our planet called the magnetosphere, which deflects solar wind gusts. (Mars, which does not have a protective magnetosphere, has lost much of its atmosphere as a result of solar wind erosion.)
http://spaceweather.com/glossary/imf.html
 

zoobyshoe

Bipedal Hairy Critter
5,817
1,268
SOS2008 said:
A quick Internet search with "Magnetic Field and Atmosphere" yielded several sites on the topic. There are different variables, the sun's magnetic field or "Interplanetary Magnetic Field" or "IMF," the solar winds, the density of a planet's atmosphere, etc.

http://spaceweather.com/glossary/imf.html
That site links to this site:

The Solar Wind at Mars
Address:http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2001/ast31jan%5F1.htm [Broken]

which explains how Mars was stripped of its atmosphere by solar winds when its magnetic field stopped working. That stripping is, apparently, ongoing.

I think we are probably safe from a seriously damaging amount of atmospheric stripping so long as the magnetic field doesn't take too long to flip.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
4,356
47
okay, that explains the origin of that remarkable statement, loosing atmosphere due to a lack of magnetosphere. But something doesn't add up.

Mars does have a magnetosphere, on the other hand "http://www.worldalmanacforkids.com/explore/space/venus.html [Broken] lacks a magnetic field of its own, but the solar wind seems to generate an induced magnetosphere, probably by a dynamo action involving its own magnetic field". However, despite lacking a magnetic field of its own, Venus has the densest atmosphere by far.

So if we go with the explanation (magnetosphere sustains atmosphere) then Mars and Venus both seem to falsify it and worse, if we scrutinize a http://www.earthsci.unimelb.edu.au/mars/icar6398.pdf [Broken].
 
Last edited by a moderator:

zoobyshoe

Bipedal Hairy Critter
5,817
1,268
Yes, mars has a magnetospere, but the site you linked to says it is only 1/800 as strong as earths. The site I linked to (via SOS) says that the martian magnetic field is very degraded and spotty, there are only certain places you can get a reading as strong as earth's.

So, magnetosphere does protect atmosphere, but it has to be of a certain strength to do so. Apparently, Venus' unconventionally generated magnetosphere is of the correct strength.
 

SOS2008

Gold Member
0
0
Ultimately it appears unlikely that Earth will become like Mars due to loss of magnetic force field. Perhaps Earth is more likely to become like Venus because of the greenhouse affect?
 

The Physics Forums Way

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Members online

Top