The discussion revolves around the physics of monochromators, specifically focusing on the theoretical understanding required to grasp their operation. Participants explore the relevance of different optics approaches, including wave optics and electromagnetic (EM) optics, in the context of monochromator functionality.
Participants express differing views on the necessity of wave versus electromagnetic optics for understanding monochromators, indicating a lack of consensus on the best approach to take.
Participants highlight the dependence on the specific mechanisms used in monochromators (such as prisms or diffraction gratings) and the implications for the required theoretical background.
Valce said:Thanks! By the way, should I be focusing more on wave or electromagnetic optics to understand how a monochromator works?
Well, actually, it depends: if he wants to go deep into refraction and dispersion mechanisms (in the case the monochromator uses a prism an not a diffractio grating to separate the wavelength), he needs EM too.cesiumfrog said:It's a simple wave effect, so EM is unnecessary.
lightarrow said:Well, actually, it depends: if he wants to go deep into refraction and dispersion mechanisms (in the case the monochromator uses a prism an not a diffractio grating to separate the wavelength), he needs EM too.