Motor inductance calculation producing complex numbers

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Jamie1234
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
Corroborating the output of a trivial equation
Hello.
I would like to replicate the plot (a figure) provided in an example. The example is presented in a journal paper and shows the calculation for the inductance of a motor with known torque and angular speed.
Below is the figure, and the table of parameters provided in the paper

Graph of La (mH) against Ψa (Wb) showing five borders (Border 1 to Border 5) and a dashed line labelled Ψd min = 0, with a shaded region bounded by the borders containing two operating points, MPP 1 (red square) and MPP 2 (blue triangle).

Table 1, Operating points and electrical specification: operating point 1 at speed Na 1500 min-1 and torque Ta 10 Nm; operating point 2 at speed Nb 3000 min-1 and torque Tb 5 Nm; armature current limit Iam 20 A; induced voltage limit Vom 100 V; inverter voltage limit Vlim 160 V.

Border 2 in the above figure is given by equation 10, below:
Equation (10): La = (1/Iam) times the square root of (Vom/ωbase)² minus Ψa², followed by a sentence referring to base speed Nbase (= Na) in Fig. 2.

Calculating the inductance for the values of magnetic flux 0.24:0.05:0.260 as shown in the Figure, we obtain the values:
La_10 = 0.0000 + 0.0115i, 0.0000 + 0.0118i, 0.0000 + 0.0120i, 0.0000 + 0.0123i and 0.0000 + 0.0126i
Am I going mad?? :/ .

Code snippet:
N_a = 1500 % Speed [RPM]
Ta = 10 % Torque [Nm]
I_am = 20 % Armature current limit [A]
V_om = 100 % induced voltage limit [V]
V_lim = 160 % Voltage limit of inverter [V]
Flux_PM = [0.240:0.005:0.260]
La_10 = 1 / I_am * sqrt((V_om/N_a)^2 - Flux_PM.^2)
plot(Flux_PM, La)
 
Attachments
  • Table 1, Operating points and electrical specification: operating point 1 speed Na 1500 min-1, torque Ta 10 Nm; operating point 2 speed Nb 3000 min-1, torque Tb 5 Nm; armature current limit Iam 20 A; induced voltage limit Vom 100 V; inverter voltage limit Vlim 160 V.
    1729664414363.png
    16.7 KB · Views: 105
  • Table 1: Operating points and electrical specification. Operating point 1: speed Na 1500 min-1, torque Ta 10 Nm. Operating point 2: speed Nb 3000 min-1, torque Tb 5 Nm. Armature current limit Iam 20 A, induced voltage limit Vom 100 V, inverter voltage limit Vlim 160 V.
    1729664441274.png
    16.7 KB · Views: 96
Welcome to PF.
Jamie1234 said:
Am I going mad?? :/ .
You have imaginary inductance values, so it may drive you mad.

I suspect the subtraction within the square root is doing that to you. You will need to check the absolute values of those variables before subtraction, one or both of them would appear to be wrong. Is one dependent on the other, and you are not evaluating that deeper dependency ?
 
Hi Bluncore. Thanks for your reply. Yes, mad as a hatter.

Yes, it's the subtraction in the square root as you mention. What gives me pause / confuses me; the paper was peer reviewed and published, the figure was constructed, and the results validated (in the paper). So it must be I that is mad..?

However; looking at the figure and table.
If we take a value on the x axis (flux linkage), say.. psi_a = 0.240, and from the table (and equation) we have, omega_base = Na = 1500 [RPM], and v_om = 100 [V], we obtain:
sqrt( ( v_om / omega_base)^2 - 0.240^2) = sqrt( (100 / 1500)^2 - 0.240^2) = sqrt( 0.0044 - 0.0576).

And yet, in the figure, for psi_a = 0.240 we have a value for the inductance of ~ 10.5 e-3 (shown in the figure to be the first point of boundary 2).

So who's crazy? and how has this magical value been obtained I wonder.
 
Last edited by a moderator: