Need help solving a combination for n

  • Thread starter Thread starter ms. confused
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Combination
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the combination equation nC3 = 10, leading to the cubic equation n³ - 3n² + 2n - 60 = 0. Participants clarify the correct approach to eliminate the factorial in the denominator by multiplying by 3!, resulting in the adjusted equation. The valid solution for n is determined to be 5, while the negative solution of -1 is dismissed as incorrect after verification. The conversation emphasizes the importance of guiding rather than directly solving problems to enhance learning. The final confirmed solution is n = 5.
ms. confused
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Need help solving a combination for "n"

I've been unable to solve the following combination for "n":

nC3 =10

I got this equation : n³ - 3n² + 2n -30 = 0

But I can't find a common factor of 30 that can be plugged into the equation to equal zero. Am I solving this incorrectly perhaps? Should I be doing something different?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You mistake is with the 30. How did you get that ?
 
I ended up with n³ - 3n² + 2n / 3! = 10 so I just multiplied the 3 by the 10 to get rid of the denominator. Come to think of it 3!=6 so maybe it should be 60 instead right?
 
Yeah perfectly right
what you get is

n^3 - 3n^2 + 2n - 60 = 0

Solving for n
n = 5 or -1

neglecting -1

The solution is n=5

5C3 = 10
 
ms. confused said:
Come to think of it 3!=6 so maybe it should be 60 instead right?

That's right.

Prasanna, the policy here is that we do not solve the problem for the poster, but give suggestions or point out errors. That way, the poster will actually learn how to go about problem solving.
 
Thank you for the help!
 
Gokul43201 said:
Prasanna, the policy here is that we do not solve the problem for the poster, but give suggestions or point out errors. That way, the poster will actually learn how to go about problem solving.

Oops! Sorry I did not know that!
I will take care hereafter!
 
prasanna said:
Yeah perfectly right
what you get is

n^3 - 3n^2 + 2n - 60 = 0

Solving for n
n = 5 or -1

Are you sure -1 is a solution? If you plug the value into the original cubic, you get -66, not 0.
 
Yeah right
n = -1 is indeed wrong
n = -1 + sqrt(11)i
or
n = -1 - sqrt(11)i
 
Back
Top