Negative potential energy vs Positive potential energy

In summary: When I was reading about surface tension I came through the following line - ' The molecules at bulk inside the fluid has lesser negative potential energy than those on the surface.' In this context, what does lesser negative potential energy mean?So the one with positive potential energy is not stable?
  • #1
Kaushik
282
17
What is the physical difference between negative potential energy and positive potential energy?

PS- When I was reading about surface tension I came through the following line - ' The molecules at bulk inside the fluid has lesser negative potential energy than those on the surface.' In this context, what does lesser negative potential energy mean?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Kaushik said:
Summary: Negative potential energy vs Positive potential energy

What is the physical difference between negative potential energy and positive potential energy?

One is attractive, and has the possibility of having a bound state, the other is repulsive and probably has no bound state.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes Kaushik
  • #3
ZapperZ said:
One is attractive, and has the possibility of having a bound state, the other is repulsive and probably has no bound state.

Zz.
So the one with positive potential energy is not stable?
 
  • #4
Kaushik said:
So the one with positive potential energy is not stable?

Define "stable".

Zz.
 
  • #5
ZapperZ said:
Define "stable".

Zz.
Stable means that the particle is confined to a space. So when it is less stable, it is confined within a larger area.
PS - this is my understanding
 
  • #6
Kaushik said:
Stable means that the particle is confined to a space. So when it is less stable, it is confined within a larger area.
PS - this is my understanding

That's not my definition of "stable". Why not just use the term "bound state" the way I stated it? An unbound state is not "unstable".

"confined within a larger area" is still a bound state! "large" is relative.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes Kaushik
  • #7
ZapperZ said:
That's not my definition of "stable". Why not just use the term "bound state" the way I stated it? An unbound state is not "unstable".

"confined within a larger area" is still a bound state! "large" is relative.

Zz.
I don't know about bound state.
 
  • #8
Kaushik said:
I don't know about bound state.

I also don't know what you don't know.

Zz.
 
  • #9
ZapperZ said:
I also don't know what you don't know.

Zz.
What is BOUND STATE?
 
  • #10
Kaushik said:
What is BOUND STATE?

See, this is another example where you try to go one step forward, but we end up having to take 2 steps back. It happens when you are trying to ask something beyond what you can understand, or if you are asking something without proper context. In this case, you notice that you never included any kind of context of what you mean by "positive" and "negative" potential energy.

So there is a HUGE missing info here, especially with regard to whether this is just classical physics idea of negative and positive potential energy, or if this were to included quantum mechanics.

Because I don't know what you don't know, and you don't seem to want to let us know what you know and don't know, I will have to prod you. I hate to now have to explain what a "bound state" is because I can already anticipate that I will have to then explain my explanation, which is what I'm doing now (1 step forward, 2 steps back).

So instead, I will ask you to go back to your original question. Why don't you sketch out the profile of what you THINK is a positive and negative potential energy, i.e. sketch out a graph of PE versus distance from the source.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes Kaushik
  • #11
@Kaushik If a proton and an electron are in the ground state then they are expected to be close together, or bound, and importantly the expected distance does not change over time. As you add internal energy to the system the electron is expected to be further away from the proton, but that expected distance does not change over time so it is still bound. If you add enough energy then the system becomes unbound and the expected distance increases arbitrarily over time. The hydrogen atom is now ionized.
 
  • #12
ZapperZ said:
See, this is another example where you try to go one step forward, but we end up having to take 2 steps back. It happens when you are trying to ask something beyond what you can understand, or if you are asking something without proper context. In this case, you notice that you never included any kind of context of what you mean by "positive" and "negative" potential energy.

So there is a HUGE missing info here, especially with regard to whether this is just classical physics idea of negative and positive potential energy, or if this were to included quantum mechanics.

Because I don't know what you don't know, and you don't seem to want to let us know what you know and don't know, I will have to prod you. I hate to now have to explain what a "bound state" is because I can already anticipate that I will have to then explain my explanation, which is what I'm doing now (1 step forward, 2 steps back).

So instead, I will ask you to go back to your original question. Why don't you sketch out the profile of what you THINK is a positive and negative potential energy, i.e. sketch out a graph of PE versus distance from the source.

Zz.
When I was reading about surface tension I came through the following line - ' The molecules at bulk inside the fluid has lesser negative potential energy than those on the surface.' In this context, what does lesser negative potential energy mean?

My interpretation -
The molecules inside the fluid are surrounded by other molecules. Those molecules attract the one at the center. So the net force is 0. It is 'stable' i.e., it does not move. Hence, it is considered to have less energy. Where as the molecules at the center experience a net downward force. This means that the molecules are 'less stable'. Due to this extra energy, they try to minimize their surface (using the extra energy) to get minimum energy possible. If we are to increase the surface area then we must do work on it.
 
  • #13
Kaushik said:
what does lesser negative potential energy mean?
Less negative means greater. So the potential energy of the molecules in the bulk is greater than those on the surface.
 
  • Like
Likes Kaushik
  • #14
Dale said:
Less negative means greater. So the potential energy of the molecules in the bulk is greater than those on the surface.
So we must do some work to displace the molecule? The energy required to move the molecules in bulk is greater than those on the surface. Isn't?
 
  • #15
Kaushik said:
So we must do some work to displace the molecule? The energy required to move the molecules in bulk is greater than those on the surface. Isn't?
It would require energy to move the molecule from the surface to the bulk. It would not necessarily require energy to move surface molecules around the surface or bulk molecules within the bulk.
 
  • Like
Likes Kaushik

What is negative potential energy?

Negative potential energy is a measure of the energy that an object possesses due to its position or configuration in a system. It represents the potential for the object to do work by moving towards a lower energy state.

What is positive potential energy?

Positive potential energy is a measure of the energy that an object possesses due to its position or configuration in a system. It represents the potential for the object to do work by moving towards a higher energy state.

What is the difference between negative and positive potential energy?

The main difference between negative and positive potential energy is the direction of movement. Negative potential energy represents the potential for an object to move towards a lower energy state, while positive potential energy represents the potential for an object to move towards a higher energy state.

How is potential energy related to kinetic energy?

Potential energy and kinetic energy are two forms of energy that are interrelated. Potential energy can be converted into kinetic energy, and vice versa. When an object moves from a higher potential energy state to a lower one, its potential energy decreases and its kinetic energy increases.

What are some examples of negative and positive potential energy?

An example of negative potential energy is a ball sitting at the top of a hill, as it has the potential to roll down to a lower energy state. An example of positive potential energy is a stretched spring, as it has the potential to release its stored energy and return to its relaxed state.

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
999
Replies
10
Views
901
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
628
Back
Top