No Electrons, No Forces: What's the Result?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dadnaya
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electrons Forces
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the concept of atoms without electrons, specifically addressing what happens when two positively charged atoms, or ions, are brought close together. An atom without electrons is referred to as a nucleus, and it is possible for an atom to exist in a state where it has lost its electrons, resulting in a positive charge. When two positively charged ions are forced together, they typically repel each other due to their like charges, and significant energy is required for any complex interactions to occur. The conversation also touches on the broader topic of states of matter, indicating that the focus is on understanding atomic interactions rather than traditional states like solid, liquid, or gas. Overall, the key takeaway is that without electrons, atomic interactions are fundamentally altered, primarily leading to repulsion between positively charged ions.
dadnaya
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Well, when 2 atoms get close, we don't feel the touch between them but the forces between electrons. So what will happen if there's atom with no electrons, so any other atom with electrons will be able to really "touch" it( because there would be no force between electrons). What will happen then?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
What is an atom without electrons?
 
Borek said:
What is an atom without electrons?
Atom that has no electrons, let's say the H will "give" the 1 he has, will he stay with no electrons I guess?
 
Charge?
 
Borek said:
Charge?
Is it possible for an atom to have no electrons?
 
Yes. Borek wants you to mention ( or look up) "states of matter". There are four. He does not want solid, liquid, or gas, so it must be ______
 
What would happen if you tried to force two atoms together, each of which was positively charged?
 
An atom with no electrons is called a 'nucleus'. What can happen when you force two together is a large part of nuclear physics which relieves us here of a duty to respond because this is the wrong forum. :D
One thing I know can happen is they just bounce off each other. If I am not mistaken for more complicated things to happen the collisions have to be at such high energies that it doesn't matter whether the electrons of an atom are there or not. So the question might be put in another forum, but I don't think there is a very brief answer.
 
So far nobody used word I was hoping for - ion. Ions are charged. Ions made by stripping electrons from the neutral atoms are positive. That points to the simplest possible answer about how they will interact. I doubt OP wanted anything more elaborate.
 
Back
Top