# Paradox found in my first relativity sheet

Tags:
1. Oct 31, 2016

### Toby_phys

We have got some SR work to do, however we have only had 1 introductory lecture. I have a problem with one of the problems.

Question: A rod of 1m parrallel to the x-axis, travels at un-relativistic speeds at 45 degrees. It passes through a slit - also parallel to the x axis - that is 1.1 meters wide.

Now assume the rod travels at 0.8c, does it fit through, look at it from both viewpoints, the rod and the slit?

In short, my answer was: I only need to look at the x velocity, y velocity will not cause the slit to shrink. X vlecocity = 0.8cos45 c

If you look at it from the slit's frame, the rod shrinks to about 0.8m and still fits. However if you look at it from the rod's frame, the slit shrinks to 0.9m, the rod doesn't fit.

How is this paradox resolved?

2. Oct 31, 2016

### Staff: Mentor

What happens to the "parallel to the x-axis" condition?
The y velocity is relevant.

3. Oct 31, 2016

### Ray Vickson

No. in the rod's rest-frame the slit does NOT shrink; it is perpendicular to the direction of motion, so is not affected.

4. Oct 31, 2016

### Toby_phys

Here is a diagram. How is the slit perpendicular to the motion

5. Oct 31, 2016

### Ray Vickson

Sorry; I mis-read the question.