Periscope reflection, but it seems backwards

  • Thread starter Thread starter heatherro92
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Reflection
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding how images are formed by two mirrors in a periscope setup. Participants emphasize the importance of extending the mirrors to determine the correct image positions, noting that images in flat mirrors appear directly behind them and are not magnified. There is confusion regarding the correct answer choices, with participants debating the implications of perpendicular lines and distances in relation to the mirrors. The concept that the line joining an object and its image must be perpendicular to the mirror is reiterated. Ultimately, the discussion aims to clarify the principles of reflection and image formation in mirrors.
heatherro92
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Screen Shot 2013-04-04 at 8.55.28 PM.png


Screen Shot 2013-04-04 at 8.55.32 PM.png


This is the question and the answer choices. I thought it would be mirror one creates E and mirror 2 creates F, but It's not... help?
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2013-04-04 at 8.55.32 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2013-04-04 at 8.55.32 PM.png
    3.4 KB · Views: 443
Physics news on Phys.org
Then I thought the answer might be C and G, but that's also incorrect, I'm just not sure what to do!
 
heatherro92 said:
View attachment 57485

View attachment 57487

This is the question and the answer choices. I thought it would be mirror one creates E and mirror 2 creates F, but It's not... help?

Extend the mirrors 1, so that you can find a point perpendicularly behind the mirror, and the same distance behind as well - as always happens with a flat mirror.

Now extend mirror 2 and repeat the above step for the final image position.
 
Perhaps remember that mirrors don't magnify an image so the image can't appear closer than the distance a light ray takes from the object to the eye via the mirrors.
 
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror
 
heatherro92 said:
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror
As PeterO says, extend mirror 1 (in this case, up and to the right). If the object is at O and the image is at point X then you should find that the mirror perpendicularly bisects OX. That is not true of OB.
 
heatherro92 said:
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror

You got B by extending the line from the object past the end of the existing mirror 1. That line is not perpendicular to the mirror.

I said extend mirror 1 - especially up to the right - then draw a line from the object that forms a right angle with the mirror.

Images in plane mirrors are DIRECTLY behind the mirror - so the line joining an object and and image is always perpendicular to the mirror.
 
heatherro92 - Try this experiment. Go to the bathroom and stand facing the mirror. Turn 45 degrees to the right. Does the image in the mirror stay in position A or move to position B ?
 

Attachments

  • Mirror.png
    Mirror.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 521
Back
Top